Let me tell you the story of Timothy Bancroft. It’s a good one, and if you haven’t heard it, I think you’ll like it.
Bancroft was a smart and shrewd investor. He dodged the Panic of 1857, which he said was due to “easy money policies” and “overconfident speculation in the railroads and farmlands of the Western states.”
Instead, Bancroft said you should “buy good securities, put them away and forget them.” He thought the best investments were those “dealing in essential commodities that the Union and the world will always need in great quantities.”
When Bancroft died, he left an estate of $1.3 million. As Adam Smith (George Goodman) points out in his book The Money Game – from which this tale comes – “If you remember that those are untaxed mid-19th-century dollars, and that a full eight-course meal at Delmonico’s cost less than a dollar at the time, that is quite a fortune.”
What did Bancroft own? He owned good stuff from the earth. He owned Southern Zinc and Gold Belt Mining. Hard assets. (Although he did own a couple of questionable things that, I am sure, seemed like good ideas at the time, like American Alarm Clock.)
Sounds smart, right?
It wasn’t. And here is where Bancroft erred.
He made it so his heirs couldn’t touch that portfolio for a time, because he wanted them to hold onto these investments. By the time they could access the estate, it was worthless. Zero. Zip. Nada.
Bancroft’s tale reminds us that nothing is a good idea all the time.
Commodities in the ground are worthless…unless there are people that can extract them and sell them at a profit. It is men and machines that give commodities their value. Commodity businesses should be treated as businesses first and commodities second. And no business is immune to market forces, which, at times, can smash them to smithereens. Poor old Bancroft seems to have forgotten this when he socked away his gold and zinc companies.
The point is that you must stay flexible on your thinking. Fall in love with no commodity. And no matter how much you like a commodity, before you invest in a producer, be sure to think hard about whether it is a good business or not.
Natural gas makes the point as well as any commodity. Natural gas has been, for the most part, a lousy investment during the last few years. In fact, it is the only commodity in the CRB Index of commodities to post a negative return during the last 24 months.
But natural gas might be on the rebound…
Two weeks ago, Chevron came out and said US gas prices need to rise. The Financial Times reported: “George Kirkland, Chevron’s head of oil and gas exploration and production, said the industry needed prices ‘in the $6s and $7s’ in the long term to cover the cost of investment.”
I agree with him. In fact, I’ve been saying this for a couple of years, and I’ve been wrong about natural gas for a couple of years. I would’ve thought it would be in the $6s and $7s already.
Contango Oil & Gas (AMEX:MCF) is a stock I recommended to the subscribers of Capital & Crisis back in January 2009 when gas was in the $5s. The stock has not set the world on fire, but it has done pretty well considering the fact that natural gas prices have been going nowhere but down.
I still consider Contago an excellent play on a natural gas recovery. The company would mint money if gas got into the $6s and $7s.
In the meantime, Contango is a good enough business that it can still do all right at low natural prices. I am currently looking at new natural gas ideas for our portfolio. Compared to nuclear, natural gas looks real good. That’s where the private money is going.
Natural gas utilities are much cheaper in upfront costs. The payback on your investment is much quicker. They are perceived as safer. Natural gas is also a clean-burning fuel. We also have lots and lots of cheap gas in North America.
Finally, as I’ve written a lot about before, the global LNG trade is set to expand greatly over the next several years. LNG is liquefied natural gas. It’s what will take natural gas from being a local commodity to a global one. The long-term opportunity is tremendous for North American gas producers. They can sell nat gas in Europe or Asia for prices more than double what they get at home.
The LNG story is already out and unfolding, as shown by the 156% rise in the stock price of Chart Industries (NASDAQ:GTLS), which puts together the Erector Sets of the LNG trade. But North American natural gas itself remains a cheap commodity against a backdrop of solid demand and the opportunity of exporting it in large quantities in the future.
It’s time to buy natural gas, again. Natural gas may not hit $13 again for a long time, but $6-7 natural gas prices seem a likely scenario, and there are a host of stocks that will be worth two or three times the price at such levels.
Also, as our experience with Contango shows, the downside is low if you pick stocks that are low-cost producers and that make money even in a low-price environment. No matter how I feel about the commodity, I always come back to looking at these things as businesses. They have to make sense as is, or no dice. Preferably, without government support.
And I always remember the tale of Timothy Bancroft. In markets, nothing is good enough to put away and forget. An investor must keep his head in the game. When the facts change, so must his opinion.
Chris Mayerfor The Daily Reckoning
We asked. You answered.We asked you, the Daily Reckoning readers, to submit your ideas for the “Trade of the Decade.” You responded with a flood of excellent responses. We regret that we cannot publish them all.Yesterday, we presented some of your submissions. Today, we present a few more. So without further ado, here’s goes:Reader B. […]
Chris Mayer is managing editor of the Capital and Crisis and Mayer's Special Situations newsletters. Graduating magna cum laude with a degree in finance and an MBA from the University of Maryland, he began his business career as a corporate banker. Mayer left the banking industry after ten years and signed on with Agora Financial. His book, Invest Like a Dealmaker, Secrets of a Former Banking Insider, documents his ability to analyze macro issues and micro investment opportunities to produce an exceptional long-term track record of winning ideas. In April 2012, Chris released his newest book World Right Side Up: Investing Across Six Continents.
The S&P 500 just clocked a new closing high last week, while the Dow and the Nasdaq both fell just short or their previous highs. But under the surface, you’ll find a few bits of evidence pointing toward lower prices. For the record, there probably won’t be a market crash. You don’t have to sell everything you own and move to the wilderness. However, there are seeing several warning signs that could point to market weakness. Greg Guenthner explains…
US unemployment rates are some of the most dubious and debatable numbers in economics. And when you look at how the government fudges them it's easy to see why. Today Jim Mosquera attempts to make sense of them, and includes an insightful commentary on another controversial topic: minimum wage. Read on...
Over the years, the feds have made it increasingly difficult for you to maintain any semblance of financial freedom. So today, Addison Wiggin details one strategy that will go a long way to keeping them at bay, and allow you to keep more of your hard-earned money in the process. Read on...
Today Frank Holmes shows how tracking the past history of the Federal Reserve's Funds Rate Cycle can be a powerful prediction tool for gold investors. Specifically, he points out why this is the beginning of a period in the cycle that's historically favorable for the price of gold, and how you can take advantage of it. Read on...
Real health care reform isn't going to come in the form of laws, rules, and regulations. It's going to come from people looking to do things differently and find savings where none previously existed. And that means developing new technology that expands medical coverage. Now if only government got out of the way...