Addison Wiggin

“Disasters,” writes the bow-tied celebrity economist Peter Morici, “can give the ailing construction sector a boost, and unleash smart reinvestment that actually improves stricken areas and the lives of those that survive intact.”

Oy… Hurricane Sandy appears to be having a number of perverse effects…

  •  Knight Capital — the outfit that sent more than 100 stocks on wild swings in August thanks to a “software glitch” — ran into generator problems at its New Jersey headquarters yesterday and couldn’t execute orders from brokers
  •  ADP accidentally released revisions to its September jobs report a day early — about which more below
  •  And economists who should know better are playing up the storm’s “stimulus” effects.

Look! It’s a boon to the auto industry!

“Rebuilding after Sandy,” Mr. Morici writes at Yahoo Finance, “especially in an economy with high unemployment and underused resources in the construction industry, will unleash at least $15-20 billion in new direct private spending.”

Oy.

Mr. Morici is hardly alone. “You certainly don’t want to get a stimulus out of disaster,” adds Mesirow Capital’s Diane Swonk, “but they certainly do tend to stimulate.

“Much of it is infrastructure spending,” she tells MarketWatch, “so the subways, the electrical grid, the downed power lines, the roadwork, the overtime on that. That’s the initial stuff that’s done immediately, along with window replacement.”

Window replacement?

Really?

“The broken-window fallacy,” wrote Henry Hazlitt in his 1946 gem Economics in One Lesson, “under a hundred disguises, is the most persistent — and rabble-rousing — misunderstanding in the history of economics.”

Taking his cue from the 19th-century French economist Frederic Bastiat, Hazlitt tells the story of a vandal who breaks a bakery window. The baker supposedly stimulates the economy with his purchase of a new window. Never mind that he’d hoped to buy a new suit with the money and the glazier’s gain is the tailor’s loss.

“No new ‘employment’ has been added,” Hazlitt sums up.

Here, the clumsy Morici, likely aware of this reality, tries to justify his position by pointing out that many storm victims will “rebuild larger than before.

“On the shore,” he says, “older smaller homes on large plots are replaced by larger dwellings that can accommodate more families during the summer tourist season. The Outer Banks of North Carolina saw such gains several decades ago after rebuilding from a storm of similar scale.”

Um, wait a minute: Aren’t many of those homes “on the shore” insured by the federal government?

Why yes, they are: “Four months before Hurricane Sandy hit the East Coast,” Ira Stoll writes at Reason, “President Obama quietly signed legislation expanding the federal program that offers taxpayer-subsidized flood insurance to oceanfront homeowners.”

Now multifamily dwellings are covered in addition to the single-family variety. It’s right there in the catchall “transportation bill” that links your passport to your back taxes and requires a “black box” in all new cars.

Rebuilding “bigger and better” will take place with money taken out of a taxpayer’s pocket and put into the pocket of property owners who built in a flood zone.

“Net-net,” we’re still no better off.

“For the umpteeth time,” writes Jeffrey Tucker at Laissez Faire Today, “there is no upside to wealth destruction. But try telling that to the folks who calculate GDP.

“It is very likely the Sandy will be given credit for any fourth-quarter fake economic growth. After all, that’s how government affects the GDP. The more it spends, the higher economic growth appears to be.”

Look at the GDP figures that came out last Friday. We pointed out then how government spending accounted for most of the “growth.” Indeed, economists at George Mason University’s Mercatus Center figure it’s the biggest quarterly increase in federal spending in two years.

And it gets worse: Private-sector production — the stuff that doesn’t get shifted from one pocket to another, or is run up on Uncle Sam’s no-limit card — is falling.

“This is not economic growth,” says Mr. Tucker. “No matter how many economists tell us that the storm will inspire all kinds of new and wonderful things, this storm has been a disaster and a serious blow to the economy when we least needed it.”

Cheers,
Addison Wiggin

Addison Wiggin

Addison Wiggin is the executive publisher of Agora Financial, LLC, a fiercely independent economic forecasting and financial research firm. He's the creator and editorial director of Agora Financial's daily 5 Min. Forecast and editorial director of The Daily Reckoning. Wiggin is the founder of Agora Entertainment, executive producer and co-writer of I.O.U.S.A., which was nominated for the Grand Jury Prize at the 2008 Sundance Film Festival, the 2009 Critics Choice Award for Best Documentary Feature, and was also shortlisted for a 2009 Academy Award. He is the author of the companion book of the film I.O.U.S.A.and his second edition of The Demise of the Dollar, and Why it's Even Better for Your Investments was just fully revised and updated. Wiggin is a three-time New York Times best-selling author whose work has been recognized by The New York Times Magazine, The Economist, Worth, The New York Times, The Washington Post as well as major network news programs. He also co-authored international bestsellers Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt with Bill Bonner.

Recent Articles

Gold is (Once Again) Money

James Rickards

Few understand how to value gold, and even fewer understand that gold is not really an investment — it is money. Jim Rickards illustrates this point further and gives you actionable methods to accumulate wealth in gold. Read on...


Assessing a Measles Outbreak in Your Neighborhood

Stephen Petranek

With summer vacation on the horizon across the United States, kids who are carrying measles from states hard hit like California and Arizona will be mingling to with kids from other states with almost no cases. And officials are still wary about this year’s mini-epidemic. Stephen Petranek has more…


A Brief History of Currency Wars

James Rickards

Currency wars are one of the most important dynamics in the global financial system today. Jim Rickards gives a brief history of currency wars and explains the reason why they occur. Read on...


How To Make 55% In 5 Years… Right Out Of The Tap

Jody Chudley

Remember, only 0.25% of the water on our planet is usable. As Jody shows, investing in water presents a long-term opportunity to get exposure to a sector that is going to have the wind at its back for a very long time. And he’s got a great ticker to share…


How to Trade the New Fast Food Boom

Greg Guenthner

Mickey D's has a new CEO to fix this mess. No matter. This dinosaur of a fast-food chain is on the road to ruin. Ronald is dying a slow, painful (possibly diabetes-related) death. And there's nothing anyone can do about it.