Bill Bonner

Stocks were flat yesterday. Gold fell $3.

The news was mixed.

The big debate is between those who think the authorities are being too tight and those who think they are being too loose. Broadly, Europeans are on one side. Americans are on the other. The Europeans are tightening up. The Americans are letting rip. They’re both wrong, as far as we’re concerned.

It’s all nonsense. Just goes to prove our dictum that people come to think what they must think when they must think it. The Euro-feds can’t afford to think they can loosen up. Their lenders have already laid down the law: ‘Keep spending like the Greeks and we’ll hit you with Greek-style interest rates.’

Just a few weeks ago the Greeks were forced to pay 16% interest. At that rate, borrowing is out of the question. You’re effectively cut off. Because the more you borrow, the higher your interest rate. Soon, you run out of money.

As Nouriel Roubini put it, ‘austerity is not optional.’ Since it’s not an option, but a necessity, there’s no point in thinking anything else. You might like to spend more money, but you know you can’t get away with it.

The US doesn’t have to think about austerity. Not yet, at any rate. They’ve got the whole world ready to lend them money. ‘Here, take a drink of rice wine,’ say the Chinese. ‘Here is some champagne,’ say the Europeans. ‘And here’s a bottle of whiskey,’ say the jokers in the back of the room.

It is only a matter of time before Americans fall down.

Not so, say the Keynesians – led by Paul Krugman and Martin Wolf. They say it’s just a matter of managing the situation. Enjoy the party. You can pull yourself together later.

“The best policy is to put together measures that sustain strong growth in demand in the short run,” writes Wolf in yesterday’s Financial Times, “while constraining the huge deficits in the long run. It’s like walking and chewing gum at the same time. Why should that be so hard?”

Meanwhile, Richard Koo probably knows more about this sort of economy than anyone. He’s lived with it in Japan for the last 20 years. So, what does Koo think?

He says you can forget about a quick recovery. Japan has been hoping for a quick recovery for the last 20 years. It’s been following the Krugman-Wolf approach – stimulating demand with fiscal policy. That is, it spends more than it collects in taxes, counting on the extra government spending to light a fire under the private sector.

But that won’t happen, says Koo. The private sector won’t start spending again until it has finished de-leveraging. Paying off debts takes a long time – especially when the government keeps bailing you out. So prepare for a long slump in the private sector economy.

So far, so good. But then Koo takes the classic Keynesian line. Like Krugman and Wolf, he believes the government should replace private spending with spending of its own.

It sounds logical enough. At least if you don’t think about it too much. An economy is the sum of spending and investing. If the private sector goes into a funk and stops spending and investing, the economy shrinks. So why shouldn’t the government step in and help out a bit?

Koo thinks so. Krugman, who won a Nobel Prize in economics, thinks so. Wolf, who heads up the worlds’ most influential financial journal, thinks so.

Well, count on us, dear reader. We don’t think so.

A real economy is much too complex for such simpleminded management. It is an organic system that delivers to people what they want (markets give them what they deserve). An economy doesn’t necessarily correspond to what academic economists think it should be…or necessarily do what they think it ought to do…or sit still long enough so they can tell what the hell it is doing.

A real economy has a mind of its own. It doesn’t care about their GDP growth rates. Whether people lose their jobs or not is not its problem. And it certainly doesn’t intend to help politicians get re-elected.

Sometimes people want to spend. Sometimes they want to save. Keynes identified this “propensity to save,” as though it were an unpardonable sin. If the people won’t spend, we’ll spend for them, he said…or words to that effect. But why shouldn’t people be allowed to save money rather than spend it?

‘Because the economy might collapse,’ says the Krugman-Wolf-Koo crowd.

‘So what?’ answers The Daily Reckoning.

Bill Bonner
for The Daily Reckoning

Bill Bonner

Since founding Agora Inc. in 1979, Bill Bonner has found success in numerous industries. His unique writing style, philanthropic undertakings and preservationist activities have been recognized by some of America's most respected authorities. With his friend and colleague Addison Wiggin, he co-founded The Daily Reckoning in 1999, and together they co-wrote the New York Times best-selling books Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt. His other works include Mobs, Messiahs and Markets (with Lila Rajiva), Dice Have No Memory, and most recently, Hormegeddon: How Too Much of a Good Thing Leads to Disaster. His most recent project is The Bill Bonner Letter.

  • Renaldo

    My spending myself into debt is being my brother’s keeper?

  • jw

    Make it so attractive that “the people” have to spend – start with credit card interest tax deduction

  • Doug

    Very glib; astonishingly useless.
    So what? So think about it and offer an opinion that delves into impact on people’s lives.
    Don’t worry, I won’t be back.

  • malleabiz

    yeah! let it crash! then we’ll discover what really matters so we can start cutting all this economic fluff. The GDP isn’t improving anyone’s quality of life.

  • gmax275

    Keynesian economic policy is perfectly plausible assuming you actually follow ALL of it. Keynes said governments should spend more in bad times AND LESS IN GOOD TIMES, i.e. run surpluses to cool the economy down a bit and have cash reserves to spend on the rainy days.

    The problem with Krugman et al is they tend to forget that damn saving thing every time the Dow hits a new high.

    Now the debts are so large austerity is quickly becoming the only option.

Recent Articles

Boeing and SpaceX Fly Together

Stephen Petranek

Getting into space is getting more complex, and a lot cheaper. A recent launch typifies the new power of private rocketry as well as the ability of competitors like SpaceX and Boeing to cooperate to make the price tag of a launch cheaper. Stephen Petranek has more…


Forget Dinosaur Tech IPOs — Just Buy Apple

Greg Guenthner

Companies go public to rake in a few billion dollars for themselves and the underwriters. And the suckers-- sorry, investors who gobble up shares when these things come out-- usually end up losers. The stock sinks once the initial euphoria wears off. Then it levels off at a much lower price before maybe rising at a normal pace again.


Beware the Money Illusion Coming to Destroy Your Wealth

James Rickards

A money illusion sounds like something a prestidigitator performs by pulling $100 bills from a hat shown to be empty moments before. In fact, money illusion is a longstanding concept in economics that has enormous significance for you if you’re a saver, investor or entrepreneur. Jim Rickards explains...


Low Oil Prices Are A Saudi Attack On Iran — But You Can Defend Yourself

Byron King

Traders bid up oil prices this week, based on reports of major escalation of hostilities in Yemen, just south of Saudi Arabia. It’s part of Iran’s long-term strategy to surround the Saudis. Which is why Byron says the Saudis’ primary motivation in crashing oil prices last November was to weaken Iran...