To be sure, this was a mind-bending experience. I watched Steven Spielberg’s movie Lincoln on the same weekend that I read Joseph Fallon’s Lincoln Uncensored, the e-book of the week released by the Laissez Faire Club. Worlds collided.Fallon’s book, which is brilliant and the most useful Lincoln book I’ve read, sticks to the facts by organizing material from the 10 volumes of collected writings and speeches of Lincoln. The reader is given Lincoln’s own words on subjects like slavery, secession, Fort Sumter, equality of blacks and Mexicans, habeas corpus, war power, free speech, tariffs, debt, the Emancipation Proclamation, the Union, and vastly more.
Fallon (educated at American University and Columbia’s School of International and Public Affairs) is, obviously, a master researcher. His editorial notes take advantage of all modern scholarship and are carefully cited.
Lincoln emerges as the consummate politician, and I don’t mean that as a compliment. Political power was his driving principle. All else was malleable, words and rhetoric formulated as means to an end, and that end was centralization of the state. This is sadly true of his late-life sympathies to the abolitionist cause. They served his purposes well.
Fallon has added to each section some background discussion of the core issues. Just as an example, he assembles Lincoln’s pro-secession statements, such as:
“Any people anywhere, being inclined and having the power, have the right to rise up and shake off the existing government, and form a new one that suits them better… Nor is this right confined to cases in which the whole people of an existing government may choose to exercise it. Any portion of such people that can may revolutionize and make their own of so much of the territory as they inhabit.”
It’s a great statement, one that summarizes the classical liberal position for right of self-determination. Can this possibly be the same war president who ruled during the appalling bloodbath that killed 620,000 soldiers and perhaps another 100,000-plus civilians in order to prevent secession and shore up a forced union? Yes, it is. The year was 1848. He was speaking on behalf of the Texas secession from Mexico.
At the same time, Lincoln’s liberally minded words do not pertain to human rights generally. He did not oppose slavery in general. He was opposed to the extension of slavery for political reasons. By his own account, he “declared a thousand times” that that government cannot “rightfully interfere with slaves or slavery where it already exists.”
Reading Fallon’s book, the contrast between the liberating demigod of the civic religion and the undeniable reality, as illustrated through Lincoln’s own words, could not be more stark.
Then you see the movie and all the portrayed events take on a completely new meaning. Instead of a charming humanitarian, you see a clever politician drunk on power. Instead of a liberator, you see how the language of liberation was used to support despotism. Parts of the movie hint at the truth. He suppressed free speech. He assumed dictatorial powers without legal justification. He jailed critics. In the name of union, he turned the land of the free into killing fields.
Reading Fallon, two great problems with Abraham Lincoln emerge: his means and his ends. The means were themselves horrifying, and the new new Lincoln provides only a hint of it with the piles of limbs and bodies that variously appear in battlefield and hospice scenes. This war was ghastly and unnecessary (Britain ended slavery peacefully just 30 years earlier, as Thomas DiLorenzo frequently points out). He ordered mass executions. He made the Bill of Rights a dead letter.
In order to understand Lincoln’s passion for preserving the Union, you have to put yourself into a different era of federal finance. There was but one source of revenue: the tariff. There were no internal taxes. There was no “too big to fail,” because there was no central bank capable of bailing out an entire industrial base. As Lincoln himself said by way of explanation, “The tariff is to the government what a meal is to the family” (1861). The South’s ports collected 75% of all federal tax revenue. Without that revenue — that’s what secession meant — the federal government would be starved.
So in one sense, Lincoln was doing only what we’ve come to expect of presidents. One only has to imagine how Bush or Obama or any modern American president would react to the prospect of a 75% cut in incoming revenue — especially if there were no central bank to make up the difference. Would any modern president let the people go, just stand by, and let the federal government starve? Let every opportunity for graft, payoffs, spending on projects, and patronage just evaporate? No chance.
The controversy has raged for a long time about whether the Civil War was really about slavery. It depends on the meaning of “about.” In terms of Lincoln’s motivation, the Fallon book makes it indisputably clear that it was not the desire to end slavery that drove Lincoln’s prosecution of the war, but the need for national unity, which in turn comes down to enforcing the revenue stream. Anyone who knows anything about how politics operates can see this very clearly. In fact, I don’t even know why this would be a controversial claim at all. Why does the head of any state put down rebellion? To liberate people or to enslave them?
As for the motivation of the South to secede, matters become more complex. The desire to shore up slavery and protect the territory from the abolitionists played a large and even decisive role, given that most everyone assumed that slavery was essential to the South. There was also the desire on the part of Southern elites to set up a new government that could form its own trading relationships with foreign nations. And though the demand for secession is an essential right of a free people, the new Confederate government drafted, taxed, and inflated in a way that contradicts every other principle of liberty.
The lesson here is that no government or power of any size or scale can be relied upon to defend liberty. And governments in wartime come into their own, stopping at nothing to protect their power at the people’s expense.
The movie ends with a sequence that is supposed to inspire, but only gave me chills. Thaddeus Stevens has his wife read him the text of the 13th Amendment. “Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States.” He breathes a great sigh of relief.
Slavery is gone, and thank God. But what about involuntary servitude? Ask the hundreds of thousands of people now locked up for nonviolent crimes like smoking pot. Ask those who are jailed for failing to fork over enough of their earnings to the government. Ask those who are jailed for sharing files online. Ask those who are jailed for creating alternative currencies or just trying to run a business but failing to adhere to every jot and tittle of the central plan.
In the film, Stevens believes liberty has won. Yet I’m sitting in a theater full of involuntary servants. Indeed, involuntary servitude is the very essence of government. It is the very means by which government seizes control of society. A real 13th Amendment, one that actually got rid of involuntary servitude, would guarantee freedom in every sense. That is not what happened. How and why should be a concern of every citizen interested in the fate of liberty.
No one book and certainly no one movie can possibly capture the incredible complexities of this astonishing event in American history. But it seems reasonable to start with Lincoln’s own words as presented in his letters and speeches. This requires carefully going through 10 volumes of his collected works. Lincoln Uncensored has done the work for you. It is this week’s free download in the Laissez Faire Club.
Original article posted on Laissez-Faire Today
I'm executive editor of Laissez Faire Books and the proprietor of the Laissez Faire Club. I'm the author of two books in the field of economics and one on early music. My main professional work between 1985 and 2011 was with the MIses Institute but I've also worked with the Acton Institute and Mackinac Institute, as well as written thousands of published articles. My personal twitter account @jeffreyatucker FB is @jeffrey.albert.tucker Plain old email is email@example.com
Pingback: News and Politic Politics Definition in General | News and Politic
Some balance and getting near to the truth!
This is the first article I’ve seen that gets to the central issue that caused the war: the potential loss of 75% of the Feds’ revenue. I know you were just paraphrasing what was in the book, but it is appreciated.
Pingback: Articles for Sunday » Scott Lazarowitz's Blog
Pingback: Legend of Lincoln Deconstructed - GadflyRadio
Pingback: tranny web cam
Pingback: self actualization dallas
Pingback: windows doors Mississauga and Oakville
Pingback: small business idea
Pingback: unblock facebook
Pingback: make money
Pingback: cong ty seo
Pingback: DSL Anbieter
Pingback: pu erh tea review
Pingback: paxil lawsuits
Pingback: annual free credit report
Pingback: garcinia cambogia bodybuilding
Pingback: music promo
Pingback: what is pu erh tea
Pingback: movers marietta ga
Pingback: beat creator
Pingback: malpractice lawyers
Pingback: Buy Monitors
Pingback: sell backlinks
Pingback: where can i buy backlinks
Pingback: book of ra online
Pingback: great post to read
Pingback: flames love test
Pingback: improve search engine rankings
Pingback: buy links
Pingback: Going Here
Pingback: where to buy a computer
Pingback: are aliens real
Pingback: Garmin nüvi 2797LMT 7-Inch
Pingback: aktuelle comtech gutscheine
Pingback: versandkostenfrei gutschein sanicare
Pingback: gutscheincodes von medimops
Pingback: versandkostenfrei gutschein teufel
Pingback: Rao vat tong hop
Pingback: zalando lounge gutscheine
Pingback: nha hang tiec cuoi
Pingback: sportscheck gutscheincode versandkosten 2013
Pingback: gutscheincode s. oliver neukunde
Pingback: congstar gutschein versandkosten
Pingback: versandkostenfrei gutschein c&a
Pingback: bestandskunden asos gutschein
Pingback: social media
Pingback: vertbaudet gutscheinnummer
Pingback: aktuelle koffer arena gutscheine
Pingback: gutscheincode heine versandkostenfrei
Pingback: lands end gutscheinnummer
Pingback: ???? ??? ?????
Pingback: gutschein neukunden jako-o
Pingback: gutscheincodes blume2000
Pingback: gutscheincode spartoo versandkostenfrei
Pingback: amazon gutscheincode 10
Pingback: indie clothes shops sydney
Pingback: gutscheincode weltbild versandkosten
Pingback: gutscheincode frontlineshop mai
Pingback: male enhancement
Pingback: versandkostenfrei gutschein cewe
Pingback: Kendal Killings
Pingback: gutschein neukunden mirapodo
Pingback: gutscheincode redcoon mai
Pingback: getgoods gutscheincode versandkosten 2013
Pingback: zooplus gutschein versandkosten
Pingback: gutscheine baur
Pingback: gutscheincode deichmann neukunde
Pingback: dentist Cuyahoga Falls Ohio
Pingback: website seo analysis
Pingback: Mediation Minnesota
Pingback: green label pcf mojo
Pingback: IMPORTANT SOURCE
Pingback: Orthodontist Chandler AZ
Pingback: Google Analytics training
Pingback: medical website design
Pingback: Google Analytics help
Pingback: Useful reference
Pingback: obat penyubur sperma
Pingback: reverse phone numbers in usa
Pingback: tenerife forum
Pingback: learn and master guitar review
Pingback: Dr OZ Green Tea
Pingback: Google Sniper
Pingback: noclegi wladyslawowo
Pingback: how to get bigger boobs without surgery
Pingback: Green Coffee Bean Max
Pingback: discount broker
Pingback: lose 20 pounds
Pingback: southern hip hop music promoters
Pingback: best dermatologist NYC
Pingback: Katelynn Tkachï¿½
Pingback: linux web hosting
Pingback: Myles Pullem
Pingback: zynga poker chips
Pingback: acer travelmate 620 7
Pingback: Military Dog Tags
Pingback: 3 bureau credit report
Pingback: Buy Google plus followers
Pingback: Florida Homeowners Insurance
Pingback: baby shoes
Pingback: locksmith london
Pingback: new business ideas
Pingback: svetol green coffee bean extractï¿½
Pingback: pro lida
Pingback: volvo v40 u?ywane
Pingback: hap lida
Pingback: garcinia cambogia
Pingback: sat lida
Pingback: furniture stores melbourne
Pingback: SEO Singapore
Pingback: la voyance gratuite en direct par mail
Pingback: ice vending machines
Pingback: get Google Plus Circles
Pingback: Buy Google Plus Circle Followers
Pingback: voyance gratuite par mail rapide
Pingback: Video Presentation
Pingback: VMware Promo Code
Pingback: pelatihan hipnoterapi
Pingback: empower network
Pingback: creacion de paginas web
Pingback: Video Intro
Pingback: plastic surgery corpus christi
Pingback: carpet cleaners Gold Coast
Pingback: electric gibson guitars
Pingback: vmware promo code
Pingback: how to make your hair grow faster
Pingback: model train accessories
Pingback: acrylic electric guitar
Pingback: hostgator promo codes
Pingback: model railway scenery
Pingback: ??? ?????? ????????
Pingback: cheap cell phone plans
Pingback: ??? ????????
Pingback: Biggest secrets in weight loss by John Latham
Pingback: Rio Games
Pingback: hair loss women
Pingback: Window Repairs
Pingback: how to get money fast
Pingback: mortgage loan refinance rates
Pingback: traffic exchange
Pingback: Buy twitter followers
Pingback: e cig starter kits
Pingback: how to lower blood pressure fast
Pingback: sore throat causes
Pingback: lots of yourtube views
Pingback: Major Marwickï¿½
Pingback: printable bill of sale
Pingback: free bill of sale
Pingback: visual impact muscle building reviews
Pingback: factory unlock iphone 4
Pingback: treatments for heel spurs
Pingback: replica louis vuitton handbags outlet
Pingback: jumpers in san jose
Pingback: Humberto Zamperiniï¿½
Pingback: debt consolidation calculator nz
Pingback: search engine
Pingback: optimization engine search
Pingback: social media marketing company
Pingback: clothes for children
Pingback: úîåðåú ìáéú
Pingback: locksmith mordan
Pingback: diettogo coupon
Pingback: digital products
Pingback: The Glenn Orlando
Pingback: Tube Launch
Pingback: Durban Spa
Pingback: Click Here To Get A FREE Website
Pingback: foam silicone sheet
Pingback: web design london
Pingback: Sign Up for Website Hosting
Make Way for the Gold Price "Zero Hour"
After a six month rally, the Nipponese index dropped 7.3%. Is it a turning point or a small correction?
After rising 3% out of the gate after Thursday’s bloodbath, the Japanese index embarked on a wild ride.
The American Association of Petroleum Geologists was nice enough to schedule its 2013 annual convention at my hometown of Pittsburgh…
Given a choice, Bernanke will likely strangle the currency (your money)... in favor of “strengthening” the economy.
If the Maker Movement Is So Great, Where’s Our Flying Car?
IRS scandals and the dangers of dissenting opinion in America.