Eric Fry

Is America still the undisputed “Numero Uno”? Not according to the Economist Intelligence Unit’s (EIU) “Where to be Born Index.” A quarter of a century ago, America topped the list. Today, it is #16.

This quirky EIU Index attempts to measure which country will provide the best opportunities for a healthy, safe and prosperous life in the years ahead. The index links the results of subjective life-satisfaction surveys — how happy people say they are — to objective determinants of the quality of life across countries. And the idea is to forecast which country would be best to inhabit 18 years out, when a baby born today becomes an adult.

Obviously, the EIU’s assessment is not the last word on a nation’s quality of life, but it does at least provide food for thought…and it does corroborate a growing body of empirical data that suggest the American quality of life has degraded somewhat.

While playing around with some numbers on the back of a Rancho Santana cocktail napkin, for example, we stumbled upon some shocking contrasts between Nicaragua and the US — shocking to us, at least.

Last year, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) — i.e. food stamp program — in the United States spent $7.4 billion more than it did the year before. $7.4 billion happens to be almost identical to the entire GDP of Nicaragua, a nation of 5.9 million inhabitants. SNAP used its incremental $7.4 billion to feed 4.4 million of America’s poorest citizens. Meanwhile, all 5.9 million Nicaraguans — rich and poor alike — managed to “live on” $7.4 billion.

Here in Nicaragua, the government is too poor to operate a SNAP program. In fact, the Nicaraguan government is too poor to do much of anything. Not only is it too poor to feed its own poor, but it is also too poor to create a maze of government agencies to hassle its citizenry. The government’s entire annual budget is only about $1.6 billion, which is less than 1/50th the size of the SNAP budget.

These comparisons tell us little about how things ought to be, but they tell us a lot about how things are. Specifically, they tell us that the United States spends a spectacular amount of money trying to “manage poverty.” And yet, the more the US tries to manage poverty, the more poverty spreads. The ever-expanding budget of the FNS does not beget self-reliance; it begets ever-expanding government reliance.

During the last four years, the number of Americans receiving food stamps has doubled from 23 million to 46 million, while the direct cost of providing that support has skyrocketed from $30 billion annually to $71 billion. (The FNS’ total budget topped $100 billion this year).

Number of Americans Receiving Food Stamps vs. Americans With Full-Time Jobs

To continue the comparisons between the rich Americans and the poor Nicaraguans, the US spends 4.7% of its GDP on its military, while Nicaragua spends only 0.7% of its GDP. The US employs 13 times more police per 100,000 citizens than Nicaragua — 233 vs. 18. And yet, very few US cities are 13 times safer than Managua — El Paso, Texas being one of the rare exceptions.

Number of Homicides in Various Areas

These sharp contrasts are exactly what one would expect when comparing the world’s wealthiest nation to the Western Hemisphere’s second poorest nation (top prize in that category falls to Haiti). Similarly, it should come as no surprise that the median income in Nicaragua is only 1/10th of what we Americans call the “poverty line.”

Net-net, the US is still a very, very rich country and Nicaragua is still a very, very poor country. That said; several gauges of America’s economic condition have been deteriorating over recent years, at least relative to similar gauges of Nicaragua’s economic trajectory.

As the chart below illustrates, Nicaraguan GDP growth has staged a remarkable rebound from the war-torn decade of the 1980s. Meanwhile, US GDP growth has been downshifting from its robust pace of the ’80s and ’90s.

US vs. Nicaraguan GDP Growth for the Last Three Decades

More recently, the Nicaraguan economy has been producing rapid employment growth, while the US has been producing rapid unemployment growth.

Change in Employment, US vs. Nicaragua

Regrettably, as the US private sector struggles to grow, the US government’s debt burden is soaring. During the last six years, America’s federal indebtedness has increased from less than 70% of GDP to more than 100%. During that identical timeframe, Nicaragua’s government debt burden has decreased from more than 110% of GDP to nearly 70%.

Government Debt-to-GDP, US vs. Nicaragua

Why look at these trends?

Because the next 25 years will not be like the last 25 years, guaranteed. The world always changes…but not always for the better. What if that portion of the world called “America” is changing for the worse?

Just asking.

Regards,

Eric Fry
for The Daily Reckoning

Eric Fry

Eric J. Fry, Agora Financial's Editorial Director, has been a specialist in international equities for nearly two decades. He was a professional portfolio manager for more than 10 years, specializing in international investment strategies and short-selling.  Following his successes in professional money management, Mr. Fry joined the Wall Street-based publishing operations of James Grant, editor of the prestigious Grant's Interest Rate Observer. Working alongside Grant, Mr. Fry produced Grant's International and Apogee Research, institutional research products dedicated to international investment opportunities and short selling. 

Mr. Fry subsequently joined Agora Inc., as Editorial Director. In this role, Mr. Fry  supervises the editorial and research processes of numerous investment letters and services. Mr. Fry also publishes investment insights and commentary under his own byline as Editor of The Daily Reckoning. Mr. Fry authored the first comprehensive guide to investing internationally with American Depository Receipts.  His views and investment insights have appeared in numerous publications including Time, Barron's, Wall Street Journal, International Herald Tribune, Business Week, USA Today, Los Angeles Times and Money.

  • waffenss

    interesting discussion

  • tdm

    It already has.

  • Dean

    Nicaragua is a young man’s game, I think.

  • Frank K

    During the first half of the 20th century, America was a pretty decent country. There was huge immigration to the ‘promised land’, there were amazing innovations, but there was a huge but honest mistake of mismanaging the economy to result in the Great Depression. But overall, America house a bunch of honest working and creative people. A people who understand reality, that anything can go wrong.

    After winning WW2, America began to transform – fueled by a largely destroyed world. It dominated just about everything, and for about 3 decades, helped to manage for a peaceful world including struggle with communism. It paid a great price in that struggle but also gained a great deal from the open markets. On balance, the free world admire the land of the free.

    From about the 80′s on, however, a generation of people who contributed nil to WW2 began to take charge. They grew up infused in several cultural ideologies centered in ‘America Is Great’. This is when the world famous American Arrogance was born. Soon, the generations of the 90′s and millennial believe their country can do no wrong, always exceptional, greatest in the world. They began to enjoy life, spend way beyond their means, entertain to no end, reduce their education, abandon critical thinking, support all wars because they’re so much fun and America is sure to win. By the turn of the 21st century, national recklessness, gross stupidity, out of control finances, political madness, have reached a new height. American Hubris replaced Arrogance. Also, highly imperial foreign policy of the past few decades have built up enemies, resulted in a 9/11 blowback.

    Today, America finds itself locked into a black hole entirely of its own creation. When it looks around the world, it find few, very few friends. But a nation of 320 million still do not understand why it happened, and why nobody in the world care, except to protect themselves from the inevitable implosion. This is how low the once-great country has reached. Maybe it will climb out of the hole. But that will be the job those now less then 10 years of age, or yet unborn. In the meantime, 95% of the world’s population moves on – because they can without the need of an America no longer able to manage itself. And because anything America can make, including the highest tech products, some country in the world can also make.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Joanne-Williams/533861616 Joanne Williams

    Hmm, and yet you leave out that the countries ahead of the US on the “Where-to-be-born index” are all socialist governments with a much higher taxes and government spending.

  • http://www.facebook.com/keith.jagger.94 Keith Jagger

    The Worst Generation got in power in the 60′s and started placing soc security payments
    in a general fund leaving government debt in its place. This generation also
    allowed the Immigration and Nationality Act of1965 to be passed causing the ethnic makeup of the US to change which has caused numerous problems (neighborhoods changed for the worse and people were forced to leave for safety reasons and simply because people are
    hard wired to prefer people that look like themselves). The worst generation
    had the jobs, the manufacturing and cheap education. The generations that followed
    were left with the bill and today keeps a roof over their heads and lottery tickets in
    their hands.

Recent Articles

Bill Bonner
An Easy Way to Avoid Pig-Headed Mistakes

Bill Bonner

Taken individually, most people perform relatively well in their daily lives. They get up, drive to work and interact with various other people, largely without incident. But when big groups of people get together, they can be incredibly pig-headed, demanding "action" when the best course of action would simply be inaction. And before you know it, chaos ensues. Bill Bonner explains...


Attack on America’s Most Important Pipeline

Byron King

America's most precious resource isn't oil, natural gas, gold or any other commodity. But it travels through an extensive pipeline that, if severed, could signal an unprecedented breach in U.S. security. What is this pipeline, and why is it so imperative that the U.S. take steps to protect it? Byron King explains...


3 Critical Correction Warnings

Greg Guenthner

The S&P 500 just clocked a new closing high last week, while the Dow and the Nasdaq both fell just short or their previous highs. But under the surface, you'll find a few bits of evidence pointing toward lower prices. And right now, there are seeing several warning signs that could point to market weakness. Greg Guenthner explains...


Extra!
Where You Can Make $56,000 a Year Delivering Pizzas

Jim Mosquera

US unemployment rates are some of the most dubious and debatable numbers in economics. And when you look at how the government fudges them it's easy to see why. Today Jim Mosquera attempts to make sense of them, and includes an insightful commentary on another controversial topic: minimum wage. Read on...


Addison Wiggin
The Quickest, Easiest Way to Store Your Wealth Overseas

Addison Wiggin

Over the years, the feds have made it increasingly difficult for you to maintain any semblance of financial freedom. So today, Addison Wiggin details one strategy that will go a long way to keeping them at bay, and allow you to keep more of your hard-earned money in the process. Read on...