“Downgrading” is in a bull market.
If you google the phrase “credit downgrade,” your query returns 264,000 responses. But when you google “credit upgrade,” you get only 52,600 responses. Clearly, downgrading is in an uptrend.
The downgrade craze emerged slowly in the summer of 2007, as the housing boom was shifting into bust mode. By September of 2007, the ratings agencies had downgraded only $85 billion worth of mortgage-backed securities (MBS). But within one year, that number would soar to nearly $2 trillion.
And these weren’t your run-of-the-mill downgrades from AA to A, or some such. These were epic downgrades unlike anything the financial world had ever seen. More than half the nation’s 32,000 asset-backed securities (ABS) with credit ratings received downgrades. Thousands of ABS plummeted from AAA to “junk.”
The credit crisis of 2008-9 ensued. But then the Fed and Treasury joined hands to fix the whole mess. At least that’s the official storyline.
Unfortunately, the Federal Reserve and Treasury did not vanquish the downgrade cycle; they merely swept the downgrades into a different venue, like San Francisco cops sweeping the homeless from the Financial District to Market Street.
Over the last few months, the ratings agencies have been working overtime to downgrade everything from corporate credits to state governments to foreign governments. Even the US government itself, is “under review for possible downgrade.”
Clearly, something is out of whack. When so many participants in the global economy possess so little ability to repay their debts, something is clearly broken.
But maybe there’s a way to break this cycle – not with austerity and repayments, of course. That path is hopeless. Perhaps we could break the cycle by downgrading the metrics, rather than the borrowers.
Why not begin rating credit risk “on the curve?” Absolute standards are so…well…absolute. Based on absolute accounting standards, for example, the Greek government fully deserves its “junk credit” status. But surely there are other credits around the globe that are even worse than Greece. If Moody’s and S&P were rating on the curve, Greece might receive a “D,” rather than a failing grade. Imagine how much better Greek bondholders would feel…until the day of Greece’s inevitable default.
But that’s just our perspective…as glass-half-full guys. Back in the real world, where absolute standards – and a wee bit of politics – determine credit ratings, the trends are disconcerting, if not downright alarming.
“Rating activity during the first three months of 2011 marked the ninth consecutive quarter in which downgrades in the municipal sector exceeded upgrades,” a recent report from Moody’s observes. “With negative outlooks assigned to all major municipal sectors, the trend is likely to prevail for all of 2011.”
According to the report, the first quarter saw 66 municipal downgrades and 17 upgrades, a ratio of 3.9 to 1 – the second highest downgrade-to-upgrade ratio since the first quarter of 2002, trailing only the fourth quarter of 2010 when the ratio measured 4.6 to 1.
“We expect downgrades to continue to exceed upgrades throughout 2011 for states and local governments and school districts as states cope with the effects of weak revenue growth, significant spending obligations, and the loss of federal stimulus funding,” Moody’s concluded. “Local municipalities will struggle to maintain structural balance in an environment of declining state aid, lower assessed valuations, and fewer budgetary options.”
Meanwhile, sovereign credits are capturing most of the downgrade headlines – Greece’s Icarus-like plunge into “junk” status being the most conspicuous example. Based on top-down data, sovereign credits remain healthy, as upgrades continue to exceed downgrades. But theoretical credit-worthiness cannot conceal actual credit-unworthiness forever. Sovereign credits worldwide are struggling to maintain a semblance of creditworthiness, at least in appearance, if not in fact.
They are losing their struggle.
A Daily Reckoning prediction: The sovereign downgrade/upgrade ratio will deteriorate over the next several quarters.
But don’t get us wrong. We are not throwing stones at sovereign credits or municipal credits. We are throwing stones at credit, itself. No asset in the financial world illustrates the Second Law of Thermodynamics better than bonds. They degrade toward a chaotic condition faster – and more reliably – than any other asset class.
Bonds are a promise to pay. But the history of the bond market is a history of broken promises. That’s because borrowing is easy. Re-payment is difficult. The near-extinction of the American AAA credit illustrates the point.
In the early 1970s, about 60 US companies possessed a AAA rating. A decade later, that number had tumbled to 30. By the early 1990s, the ranks of AAA credits had dwindled to nearly 20, and when the new millennium dawned, only nine AAA companies remained. Seven companies managed to retain this prestigious ranking until 2009, when Berkshire Hathaway and GE slipped into the AA ranks.
Today, only five US companies can boast a AAA rating:
The downgrade cycle is still gathering momentum. Bond buyers beware.
Eric Fryfor The Daily Reckoning
Eric J. Fry, Agora Financial's Editorial Director, has been a specialist in international equities for nearly two decades. He was a professional portfolio manager for more than 10 years, specializing in international investment strategies and short-selling. Following his successes in professional money management, Mr. Fry joined the Wall Street-based publishing operations of James Grant, editor of the prestigious Grant's Interest Rate Observer. Working alongside Grant, Mr. Fry produced Grant's International and Apogee Research, institutional research products dedicated to international investment opportunities and short selling.
Mr. Fry subsequently joined Agora Inc., as Editorial Director. In this role, Mr. Fry supervises the editorial and research processes of numerous investment letters and services. Mr. Fry also publishes investment insights and commentary under his own byline as Editor of The Daily Reckoning. Mr. Fry authored the first comprehensive guide to investing internationally with American Depository Receipts. His views and investment insights have appeared in numerous publications including Time, Barron's, Wall Street Journal, International Herald Tribune, Business Week, USA Today, Los Angeles Times and Money.
Who says government can’t repay their debts? We’ve always been able to do so.
You need a drug test.
Cleary, the psychological trend is 14 trillion debt is a debt and 1000 trillion debt is also a debt. Since these all could be met with the printing press, there is not an iota of difference. All governments on earth could repay debts with the introduction of the printing press. The article tells truth.
There is a lot of very good information to think about on many of these DR articles. Then it seems like there is always somebody who throws in a political jab to spark anger. It takes our eyes off the information that we need to think about and perhaps use. Bonner, Fry, Wiggins and even young Joel have a way of getting you to think outside of normal channels. Don’t get side tracked by the political blather. Focus on what can help you.
By the way where is Mogambo? Maybe they did overrun his bunker? Without his posts my blood pressure is down and I am sleeping nights comfortably again. But I still miss the guy.
It is too late. Help does superficially on an advanced stage cancerous body.
With Janet Yellen more or less committed to keeping the money spigot open, you'd think Wall Street would be rejoicing. Yet, stocks are mostly a mixed bag right now. Oh well... No matter what stocks do, it appears the Fed and other central banks' folly will keep the Wall Street casino awash in free money for the foreseeable future. Read on...
Today, Wayne Mulligan counts down the top 5 most profitable investments in history and discusses the one thing they all have in common... and the one "golden rule" that increases your odds of doubling or even tripling your money in the markets. Read on...
When the government pumps trillions of dollars into the economy, it's not actually printing the money. It enters as digital entries in banks across the country. It's made the system fast, responsive, and unfortunately, vulnerable. And ff this network goes down, the entire world could fall apart. Bill Bonner explains...
Debtor's prison is supposed to be illegal in the U.S., but these days it's making a comeback. Today, Alexander Tabarrok explains how a simple failure to pay court fees can start to snowball, eventually ending in jail time. And he begins by focusing a keen eye on the problems going on in Ferguson, Missouri. Read on...
People assume that markets and financial instruments have some kind of long-term average they tend to flock toward. But in reality, a handful of wild swings in various directions often skew these averages to a point where the "long-term" is not at all reliable, let along predictable. Chris Mayer has more...