Transparency is essential in a free market. It enables market participants to make informed investment decisions.
Unfortunately, in America’s “free market” economy, transparency is a latchkey child. It only sees the light of day when someone breaks down the door and carries it outside. Institutions like the Federal Reserve and the Treasury explicitly and vehemently resist transparency. It is the enemy, they say, of an “independent” monetary policy.
During the crisis of 2008-9, the Federal Reserve and Treasury operated as covertly as the CIA – doling out trillions of dollars in bailouts and guarantees to a handful of coddled corporations. Those financial “black ops” produced myriad deceptions in the financial markets.
In addition to the Fed’s intended deception that insolvent financial firms are as fit as a fiddle, the Fed’s meddling also produced numerous knock-on deceptions like: the labor market is recovering, the housing market is bottoming out, the financial sector is reviving and Goldman Sachs never makes a trading loss.
The Fed’s secret meddling also produced a few very subtle deceptions – the kind that seem victimless…until you dig a little deeper.
During the crisis of 2008-9, for example, Ford Motor Company borrowed as much as $7 billion from a lending facility of the Federal Reserve. But the details of these borrowings did not come to light until just three weeks ago. And even now, very few investors – or car-buyers – seem to realize that GM and Chrysler were not the only “Big 3” car companies to receive a helping hand from the government. Ford also cashed a few government checks.
On December 3, 2008, Ford Motor Co.’s CEO, Alan Mulally, applauded the assistance the federal government extended to General Motors and Chrysler, while also declaring, “Ford is in a different position. We do not face a near-term liquidity issue, and we are not seeking short-term financial assistance from the government.”
Two years after this pronouncement, Ford remains “the auto company that did not receive a government bailout.” So pervasive is this legend, that tourists in Dearborn, Michigan can be seen wearing T-shirts like these:
Ford relishes this public perception and uses it to its economic advantage. Kudos to Ford. Now let’s look at the facts.
Just one month before Mulally declared, “We do not face a near-term liquidity issue, and we are not seeking short-term financial assistance from the government,” Ford Motor Credit had borrowed nearly $4 billion from the Fed’s Commercial Paper Funding Facility (CPFF). And just two weeks after this remark, Ford Motor Credit borrowed an additional $3 billion from the CPFF. In all, Ford borrowed $7 billion between October 27, 2008 and June 17, 2009.
Furthermore, shortly after Mulally claimed to be in a “different position” from that of GM and Chrysler, Ford’s borrowings from the CPFF placed Ford in a nearly identical position.
The Ford borrowing timeline looks like this:
10-27-08 – Ford Motor Credit borrows $1.980 billion from the CPFF10-29-08 – Ford Motor Credit borrows $990 million from the CPFF10-31-08 – Ford Motor Credit borrows $991 million from the CPFF11-18-08 – Mulally flies to Washington in the company’s corporate jet and asks for financial assistance. The event is a PR nightmare because the CEOs of GM and Chrysler also fly to Washington in private jets.12-3-08 – Mulally drives a Ford Escape hybrid to Washington and asks for a $9 billion credit line to use “if industry conditions worsen.” Mulally says he’ll work for one dollar per year if he taps the credit line.12-8-08 – Mullaly declares, “Ford fully supports an effort to address the near-term liquidity issues of GM and Chrysler, as our industry is highly interdependent and a failure of one of our competitors could affect us all… For Ford, a line of credit would serve only as a critical backstop or safeguard against worsening conditions, as we drive transformational change in our company.”12-18-08 – Ford Motor Credit borrows $1.984 billion from the CPFF12-19-08 – Ford Motor Credit borrows $992 million from the CPFF, to bring its today CPFF borrowings to nearly $7 billion. Ford would continue rolling over these loans for the next several months.1-29-09 – Ford announces a $5.9 billion loss for the quarter but insists it does not need financial help from the government.1-29-09 – Ford Motor Credit rolls over $1.488 billion of CP with the CPFF
Mulally deserves no blame for availing himself of funding that was freely – if very privately – provided by the Federal Reserve. After all, Mulally’s Wall Street counterparts were already busy tapping various credit facilities at the Fed. So can we blame Mulally for thinking to himself, “Hey, I’d like to tap that too!”?
Nor does Mulally deserve blame for failing to disclose the assistance. On the 18th page of the business plan Ford submitted to the Senate Banking Committee on December 2, 2008, the document states: “At Ford Credit, and in light of the frozen capital markets, we…are eligible for and are participating in funding programs from the European Central Bank and, more recently, the Federal Reserves Commercial Paper Funding Facility (CPFF).”
However, on the second page of that very same document, Ford states that it is “in a different situation from our competitors, in that we believe our company has the necessary liquidity to whether this current economic downturn – assuming that it is of limited duration.”
The “different situation” disclosure is the one that Mulally nurtured in his public remarks and the one that the public embraced. Mulally wasn’t lying; he was posturing. And posturing, as a tactical maneuver, can be brilliant. Certainly, Mulally’s posturing served Ford very well during the crisis…and continues to serve it well today. Therefore, Ford shareholders have every right to be pleased with Mulally’s public remarks; the champions of free markets and transparency, less so.
The point of our tale is not to cast stones at Mulally, but rather to catapult boulders at the Federal Reserve, and by extension at the exalted notion that institutionalized secrecy is an essential component of “guiding” a free market economy… In fact, if we had enough boulders, we would also catapult them at the idea that the economy requires any guidance at all from the Federal Reserve.
Thanks to the Fed’s secret dealings, companies like Ford could obtain the government’s assistance, while appearing to operate without it. That was a very convenient circumstance in the depths of the crisis…both for the bailout recipients and for the officers of bailout recipients.
“Bailout” was a very bad word in 2008. And any CEO who asked for a bailout was an unpopular guy, especially if he asked for a bailout and continued to draw a multi-million-dollar salary. Consequently, numerous CEOs offered to “work for a dollar” in order to keep the barbarians at the gate. Very few CEOs wanted to appear to be profiting at the taxpayers expense, although they clearly had no qualms about not appearing to benefit at the taxpayers expense, especially if they could actually benefit without the appearance of it.
Mulally found that path. Offer to work for one dollar if Ford ever tapped a $9 billion credit line, but continue to draw a multi-million paycheck while quietly borrowing $7 billion from the Fed.
But there’s another reason why Mulally might have accentuated the positives about Ford’s financial position, while whispering the negatives: it was a good business decision for Ford…if not a great business decision. During the crisis, Ford grabbed market share from its Big 3 rivals. Part of the reason was – and continues to be – the perception that Ford received no help from the government.
According to a survey of 1,000 adults, conducted about two months ago by the Rasmussen Reports, “Twenty-seven percent say they or someone they know has avoided buying a GM car because of the bailout and government takeover.”
“Ford did not seek a government bailout,” the Rasmussen Reports states flatly, “and 55% of Americans say they are more likely to buy a Ford car for that reason… In fact, 18% say they or someone they know has bought a Ford car just because the company did not take any bailout funding.” Not surprisingly, as the nearby chart illustrates, Ford’s market share began increasing very significantly in late 2008…and it continues to increase to this day.
Buying a good car for the wrong reason is not the worst thing someone could do. But why not let the free market and/or Consumer Reports decide which automaker deserves to sell a car? Why should the Federal Reserve play any role whatsoever in this equation?
To reiterate, we don’t blame Mulally or Ford for taking advantage of an advantageous situation. We blame the Federal Reserve (and the Treasury) for nourishing an environment of preferential treatment, non-disclosure, backroom deal-making and every other form of capricious market manipulation.
Our conclusion: Abolish the Fed and let the free markets decide who wins and loses.
Eric Fryfor The Daily Reckoning
Eric J. Fry, Agora Financial's Editorial Director, has been a specialist in international equities for nearly two decades. He was a professional portfolio manager for more than 10 years, specializing in international investment strategies and short-selling. Following his successes in professional money management, Mr. Fry joined the Wall Street-based publishing operations of James Grant, editor of the prestigious Grant's Interest Rate Observer. Working alongside Grant, Mr. Fry produced Grant's International and Apogee Research, institutional research products dedicated to international investment opportunities and short selling.
Mr. Fry subsequently joined Agora Inc., as Editorial Director. In this role, Mr. Fry supervises the editorial and research processes of numerous investment letters and services. Mr. Fry also publishes investment insights and commentary under his own byline as Editor of The Daily Reckoning. Mr. Fry authored the first comprehensive guide to investing internationally with American Depository Receipts. His views and investment insights have appeared in numerous publications including Time, Barron's, Wall Street Journal, International Herald Tribune, Business Week, USA Today, Los Angeles Times and Money.
v. nicely done.
vermont should be very proud of bernie sanders.
he should be right up there 4 person-of-the-year with Batmanke and prez0 and bilary and Bob Gates—-uno, the rest of the heroes who are saving the nation…
t.y., Sen. Sanders!
The FED is a private institution, not part of the government; Ford can technically say they didn’t get a government bailout.
The Treasury Dept. on the other hand IS a public institution. But you knew that.
Ford derived Fed money from an existing and ongoing Fed Window apparently. This, as I understand it is not unusual.
The bailouts for Chrysler and GM were completly different and unrelated and probably for much more money. Quite unusual.
Whatsa’ matta’ don’t you like mulally??
Ford agrees transparency is important. Ford Credit participated in one Federal Reserve program (CPFF) that addressed systemic failure in the Commercial Paper credit market. Ford Credit also sold Asset Backed Securities that allowed investors to participate in a separate program (TALF). These programs were not designed for a particular company or even a particular industry. Ford Credit’s participation in these programs was publicly reported as part of our SEC filings, and discussed on conference calls with media and investors. News organizations like Bloomberg, the Detroit News and the Associated Press reported on our participation. Additionally, these programs should not be confused with emergency taxpayer assistance provided to keep other automakers in business as they faced bankruptcy. Appreciate the opportunity to comment.
Ford Motor Company
In this world of insider dealings there is plenty of room for conjecture regarding what they (Ford) knew and when they knew it. Mr Soros surely knew enough to buy a load of FoMoCo and has profited handsomely. The people wearing the silly shirts are laughable at best.
Correct me if I’m wrong, but if one includes Ford’s borrowings (and intended and approved borrowings) from a government funding program to encourage ‘green’ technology, Ford now ‘owes’ more money to the Feds than GM and Chrysler combined. (And that has been the case for nearly a year.) Ford Motor Credit has a cost of capital exceeding 10% and has been virtually shut out of the commercial paper market for years, increasing its costs.
I am a graduate student who has been studying Ford for some time. Here is a question for you: I can describe the ‘subvention’ practices and procedures that exist between Ford and Ford Motor Credit nearly to the penny (that explain the low cost ads one sees on TV.) But, if one reviews Ford’s 2009 176 page annual report, one must dig and dig, and many questions remain unanswered. Sarbane-Oxley did not go far enough … large companies still hide behind ‘Consolidation Accounting,’ (probably that law’s ‘Achilles’s Heel.) Take a hard look at Ford’s bragging about dividends from Ford Credit … by my calculations, they just gave the parent its money back!
I could use some help … any insights would be highly valued!
Pingback: Joshua Jacobi cardiology
Pingback: plantacja lawendy
Pingback: Minneapolis Bike Rentals
Pingback: read the full writeup
Pingback: best email blast service
Pingback: european roulette download free game
Pingback: celebrity stars then and now
Pingback: brian austin green megan fox
Pingback: Facebook Like Button
Pingback: Samsung Galaxy S3
Pingback: home inspection staten island
Pingback: Lori Grimes
Pingback: promotional clothing
Pingback: RKXeroFlGi RKXeroFlGi
Pingback: slot machine bar
Pingback: rugged ethernet switch
Pingback: craigslist cars for sale
Pingback: teen chat rooms
Pingback: Hillview Peak
Pingback: Photography Business
Pingback: Vine Supporters and Likes
Pingback: kéfir de lait
Pingback: graffiti pictures
Pingback: carmichal moore
Pingback: need money fast
Pingback: code rio
Pingback: rio free
Pingback: Mirena Removal
Pingback: beste online casino ohne einzahlung
Pingback: Check This
Pingback: erotines prekes
Pingback: kurs zlota
Pingback: child stars gone bad
Pingback: Pulau Tidung
Pingback: Tahun Baru di Pulau Tidung
Pingback: oxford academy of dance and performing arts
Pingback: Breakfast choices
Pingback: tv advertising conversion rates
Pingback: bee removal cost estimate
Pingback: bmw headlights 525i
Pingback: silver 401k rollover
Pingback: we buy cars greensboro nc
Pingback: seguros de autos baratos
Pingback: vivere vienna
Pingback: shakira hot
Pingback: Bettyann Anstett
Pingback: server list
Pingback: display over lan
Pingback: Upfront Reputations
Pingback: 2000 bmw angel eyes
Pingback: Gia Gushiken
Pingback: Buy SoundCLoud Followers
Pingback: car key replacement
Pingback: kirby vacuum prices
Pingback: Rodrigo Nozick
Pingback: birch gold group complaints department
Pingback: coach kurt rambis
Pingback: detox patches
Pingback: visit site
Pingback: Eugene Wren
Pingback: logan airport car service
Pingback: ichitect.com | Internet Business & Marketing Magazine
Pingback: Tracey White
Pingback: Juli Tewksbury
Pingback: Get Rare And Out Of Print Books Here
Pingback: Real estate murfreesboro tn
Pingback: Fritz Hoth
Pingback: Rebbeca Ladeau
Pingback: Mariano Asano
Pingback: Christoper Dehart
Pingback: Roland Jaco
Pingback: does satiereal saffron extract work for men
Pingback: Gayle Berthold
Pingback: Loriann Janson
Pingback: Jacquelyn Marstaller
Pingback: Kiersten Boelke
Pingback: Desmond Hatch
Pingback: Ray Ecklar
Pingback: reviews for my shape lipo
Pingback: Nicky Penzien
Pingback: plantar wart treatment
Pingback: home remedies for warts
Pingback: Real Estate Law Center complaints
Pingback: florida dating sites
Pingback: pem matthew browndorf
Pingback: click here
Pingback: browndorfpem matthew browndorf
Pingback: Kenyetta Rehmer
Pingback: Mirta Stoeckert
Pingback: Albertina Ramiscal
Pingback: Harry Molima
Pingback: Merrill Kaull
Pingback: abogados almeria
Pingback: Ramon Wipf
Pingback: gestion integral de servicios
Pingback: Buy Facebook Fans
Pingback: Buy FB Fans
Pingback: VPN reviews
Pingback: get facebook photo likes
Pingback: buy facebook followers
Pingback: buy likes for facebook
Pingback: Orange county SEO
Pingback: distilling vodka
Pingback: can you buy facebook likes
Pingback: buy us facebook likes
Pingback: visitare questo sito
Pingback: Staggered Wheels
Pingback: Egypt Now
Pingback: make android app
Pingback: types of businesses
Pingback: photo likes
Pingback: skup zlota online
Pingback: buying likes on facebook
Pingback: social bookmarking
Pingback: SAP Beratung
Pingback: how to get likes on facebook photo
Pingback: buy likes facebook
Pingback: hcg oral drops
Pingback: buy facebook votes
Pingback: buy retweets and favorites
Pingback: buy 100 facebook photo likes
Pingback: buy followers on twitter
Pingback: get followers on twitter
Pingback: buy followers
Pingback: twitter followers buy
Pingback: hcg drops
Pingback: buy soundcloud followers
Pingback: Traffic Tickets
Pingback: visitors to my site
Pingback: Big Brother
Pingback: mexico temperatures
Pingback: Carpet Cleaning Utah
Pingback: rutinas de ejercicio para bajar de peso
Pingback: Conceive A Girl
Pingback: free driving record
Pingback: jessica biel imagenes
Pingback: garcinia cambogia extract reviews
Pingback: how to buy real estate
Pingback: cheap flights to florida
Pingback: узо киев
Pingback: STD Testing in New York
Pingback: Australian Aboriginal Art
Pingback: wartrol scam
Pingback: kim kardashian implants
Pingback: Zayn Malik Fan
Pingback: Best Ways To Get Pregnant
Pingback: dating in london
Pingback: free e cig trial offer
Pingback: Click For More Info
Pingback: Elder Scrolls Online Gold
Pingback: Divorce Attorney Mesa AZ
Pingback: Safest Online Dating Site
Pingback: swtor power leveling asia pacific
Pingback: book of ra online ohne anmeldung
Pingback: my website
Pingback: view more
Pingback: How to Build Your Lead List
Pingback: Defiance Scrip
Pingback: Online Casinos
Pingback: Microwave Potato
Pingback: runescape 3 power leveling
Pingback: marvel hero power leveling
Pingback: fifa 14 coins pc
Pingback: Blade and Soul Power Leveling
Pingback: runescape power leveling
Pingback: archeage gold
Pingback: AION Power Leveling
Pingback: cheap diablo 3 gold asia
Pingback: carbon marcky
Pingback: path of exile power leveli
Pingback: diablo 3 power leveling
Pingback: marko man
Pingback: Age of WuShu Liang
Pingback: intermediate algebra help
Pingback: guild wars 2 power leveling
Pingback: fifa 14 Coins
Pingback: wow power leveling
Pingback: KAL Online Geon
Pingback: Cheap diablo 3 gold eu
Pingback: rs 3 gold
Pingback: makia julpo
Pingback: graffiti images
Pingback: sat math help
Pingback: pre calculus dvds
Pingback: praxis 0061 help
Pingback: Wartrol Review
Pingback: da Vinci surgery lawsuit
Pingback: Risperdal breasts
Pingback: garcinia cambogia hca
Pingback: Payday Loans Columbus
Pingback: Brittaney Arthun
Pingback: Car Automotive News
Pingback: online business
Pingback: infrared grill
Pingback: Asbestos removal contractors glasgow
Pingback: AION è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: Malaysian Hair 14 inch MLBW 14 | Buy Hair Extensions CutieBlush
Pingback: look what I found
Pingback: NOdeposit bonuscasino
Pingback: Jobslash – Australia's #1 Free job listing website
Pingback: Buy Followers
Pingback: èˆžç¿”ä¼ è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: çœŸãƒ»ä¸‰åœ‹ç„¡åŒ è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: buy tumblr followers
Pingback: water softener san antonio water softeners
Pingback: Amtico flooring
Pingback: minecraft gratuit
Pingback: runescape 2007 gold
Pingback: mark mania
Pingback: LEGO Marvel Super Heroes Movie
Pingback: ArcheAge è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: check out here
Pingback: Find Valued Info
Pingback: universal remote
Pingback: Education and Training
Pingback: dog videos
Pingback: view video
Pingback: ãƒ©ã‚°ãƒŠãƒã‚¯ã‚ªãƒ³ãƒ©ã‚¤ãƒ³ è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: cat videos
Pingback: click to watch
Pingback: granuflo lawsuit
Pingback: ãƒ¬ãƒƒãƒ‰ã‚¹ãƒˆãƒ¼ãƒ³ è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: print finishing products
Pingback: FF14 è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: hier klicken
Pingback: FF11 è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: My Blog Title
Pingback: п»їAnyrtew Hisvong
Pingback: Tour Company Oporto
Pingback: handy orten
Pingback: presell page
Pingback: Save Business and Finance
Pingback: handyortung kostenlos
Pingback: The Science Fiction actors Fantasy website: george clooney
As long as markets exist, there will people who try to predict where they are headed. Of course, no one can know for sure. And as Greg Guenthner explains, their prognostications can sometimes do more harm than good. Read on...
A massive storm recently blanketed the U.S. northeast. And as it did, most people ran to their thermostats to keep warm. But staying warm and cozy this winter comes at a price, even with the U.S. nat gas boom in full swing. Today, Matt Insley explains why, when it comes to nat gas prices, seasonality definitely matters. Read on...
Like it or not, size does matter. But contrary to a popular saying, bigger is not always better. Especially when it comes to the size of the state. Marc Faber explains why a world of smaller states might function better than one dominated by excessively large "superpowers." Read on...
Pope Francis recently warned people to beware the "tyranny" of capitalism. Hmmm... Would that be true capitalism and trust in free enterprise? Or the crony capitalism we're currently saddled with? Bill Bonner explains why, even though capitalism is easily corrupted by the capitalists, that doesn't necessarily mean it is a bum creed. Read on...
Income inequality in the U.S. has reached epic proportions. So much so that "1%" is no longer just a simple fraction. Now it's now much more than that, used as a pejorative symbol of excessive wealth and the greed of the American upper class. Marc Faber explains why this is unfair, especially as regards U.S. tax laws. Read on...
The average postwar U.S. expansion has lasted 58 months. In the midst of major policy dislocation in Congress and at the Fed, we are at month 52 of the current expansion, which began in June 2009. But we are running out of time – and luck.