01/27/10 Paris, France – Good news and bad news. But which is which? The situation is so confused, we can’t tell.
The good news is that housing prices are going down. That’s what The Wall Street Journal says. “Home prices declined in November.” Good. People will be able to find more affordable housing.
Wait. That’s not good news, is it? Doesn’t that mean we’re still in a depression? Besides, another report says housing is going up. What to believe?
Let’s try something else… Consumer confidence rose in the latest reporting period. No argument there…
Now, that’s definitely good news, right? Nope. The better things get the more likely the feds are to clamp down on the recovery by “exiting” their stimulus efforts and reducing the deficit. That’s part of the reason stocks often decline when the news is “good” and go up when it is “bad.” Investors are afraid the feds will take away the juice. That would risk a return of the “error of ’37,”…say economists such as Paul Krugman and Richard Koo. Ignoring the calendar a bit…it would turn our president into “Herbert Hoover” Obama, as one commentator suggested.
What happened in the ’30s? Well, in the approved storyline, the feds had their stimulus foot to the floorboards…and they were happily driving right out of the depression. But fearing inflation…deficits…and a backlash against excessive spending (and believing that they were clear of the bad neighborhood) – they slowed down…they eased off their stimulus efforts in the mid-’30s. This sent the economy into another downturn and stretched the depression out for another 3 years.
It’s nonsense. What really caused the relapse of ’37 was the feds’ own meddling. But that’s not the way mainstream economists and analysts look at it. In their cockamamie view, an economy grows thanks to the good stewardship of publicly elected officials. In their view, government spending is actually BETTER than private spending. Why? Because it produces nothing of value. Really; we’re not making this up. And so what if the government doesn’t have any money? To them, money that doesn’t exist – created ‘out of thin air,’ as Keynes put it – is BETTER than real money. Because it creates consumer price inflation. Up is down. Good is bad. Better is worse. In their view, what makes a strong economy is government action. Specifically, government spending. So, anything that might incline the feds to spend less is BAD news.
According to the papers, there’s some bad news coming. ’Cause Mr. President is going to tell the nation in his State of the Union address that it’s time to put on the brakes. If we don’t, people will get the impression that government spending is out of control. We can’t have that. Because lenders might refuse to lend. Investors might refuse to invest. Voters might refuse to vote for the scalawags now in office.
On the other hand, if the Prez really does cut spending, none of the aforementioned are likely to be very happy about it. Federal spending doesn’t really make people richer; it makes them poorer. Still, appearances are what really matter. Dim economists want a president who puts into action their loopy theories. And dim voters want a president who takes action to save them from their own mistakes…especially when it means getting their hands on someone else’s money.
The stimulus offered by government spending is phony. But it appears real to the masses. Take it away and the economic consequences will appear very real too. The ‘creative destruction’ of the market will finally get to express itself. Businesses that should fail will fail. Speculators who ought to lose money will lose money. There will be blood, in other words.
Like most people, we don’t mind a little blood…as long as it’s not our own. So you can imagine how the parasites will howl when they see the knife draw near to their own arteries!
They can relax. The feds are not likely to reduce spending significantly. The deficits are structural…they’re built-in to the system…they won’t go away.
And as the depression lingers, the debt piles up…
What will happen? We don’t know. We can’t look into the future. But we can look at Japan…a country that is at least 10 years ahead of us.
Why is Japan ten years ahead? Because its stock market turned down in 1989…a decade ahead of Wall Street. And because its population is about 10 years older. And because it’s been fighting the de-leveraging process for 20 years. What can we learn? Here’s the latest from the WSJ, warning of an explosion:
“S&P lowers Japan’s outlook to negative.”
Uh oh. Not too encouraging. The rating agency told Japan that if it didn’t cut its deficits its debts would be downgraded.
Ah yes… Thanks to the Japanese, we get to see someone cross the minefield ahead of us. After 20 years, Japan hasn’t been able to get clear. But it hasn’t blown up completely, either.
But watch closely. It’s putting its feet down on some dangerous ground. Deficits have grown and grown and grown. Now, it risks an explosion with every step. This year, it will borrow $480 billion. It will receive only $405 billion in tax revenue. As far as we know, no major economy has ever run so far into the red without a blow-up.
And what can it do? They are getting the same sort of advice as Obama. They’re told they must cut the deficit to protect the currency…the economy…and the credit rating. But they’re also told that good is bad, or bad is good…that if they do the right thing – cutting the deficit – the economy will suffer. Tax revenues will fall further…widening the deficit!
The Japanese economy has become so dependent on debt-fueled government spending that, take it away and things fall apart. In the long run, that is exactly what should happen. The economy needs a shake-up…so it can rebuild on more solid foundations. But what politician wants to risk his own blood?
Bill Bonner
Since founding Agora Inc. in 1979, Bill Bonner has found success and garnered camaraderie in numerous communities and industries. A man of many talents, his entrepreneurial savvy, unique writings, philanthropic undertakings, and preservationist activities have all been recognized and awarded by some of America's most respected authorities. Along with Addison Wiggin, his friend and colleague, Bill has written two New York Times best-selling books, Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt. Both works have been critically acclaimed internationally. With political journalist Lila Rajiva, he wrote his third New York Times best-selling book, Mobs, Messiahs and Markets, which offers concrete advice on how to avoid the public spectacle of modern finance. Since 1999, Bill has been a daily contributor and the driving force behind The Daily Reckoning. Dice Have No Memory: Big Bets & Bad Economics from Paris to the Pampas, the newest book from Bill Bonner, is the definitive compendium of Bill’s daily reckonings from more than a decade: 1999-2010.
The Daily Reckoning is your premier source for making sense of the news Washington and Wall Street generate. Each business day, The Daily Reckoning calls on its stable of world-class writers and thinkers to show you how to get ahead.
Start your 100% FREE subscription to The Daily Reckoning today and you’ll get a free research report, “How to Survive the Fall of Social Security.” Simply enter your email address below to get your free report and join over 495,000 worldwide Daily Reckoning subscribers!
We Respect Your Privacy and We will
Never Share or Sell Your Email Address
I enjoy reading these kinds of articles, but can’t help thinking these broad statements without support are not worth a lot. What is this constant refrain that government spending is useless or “federal spending makes people poorer”. Math is true whatever the facts, the rest of the “factual” statements better have some history to back them up. You have to explain why building the Hoover dam or interstate highways doesn’t make people richer or help business sell, produce and distribute more.
Lighten up everybody and let’s party like it’s 1929.
BB:
Is “private capital” stepping forward to repair the decrepit condition of our “national” infrastructure; contribute their riches to national public education equally given to ALL? etc. etc……
The “free market” is an illusion that can only operate in a political and social vacuum…..
It’s not taxes collected; it’s where those monies are prioritized to go such as the absolute no productive wars this country insists on creating……
The depression of the 1930′s didn’t produce a positive DOW until I believe, 1954……..
Enjoy you writing….
harry must be out doing his part getting a new igizmo, havnt heard from him much lately
And there it is. 2014 rite round the corner! All i can say is buckle down,its gonna b an intresting ride! Bring on the days of Rome,wait a minute, were in those days right know! Lets all implode, and from the rubble will build something new that will have alittle longer shelf-life than a 100 yrs at#1! United we stand,divided we watt? Well oh-bla-dee,oh-bla-da, like goes on, hahh! LLAP all *S*
Aah rjkincaid, you are obviously new to the site. But better late than never. You do have alot to learn though. A good place to start is “Economics in one lesson” by Harry Hazlitt
Sorry, your mini correction is over. Apple tossed out another amazing product that will take the market higher. You guys don’t get it. You tried to take down the rescue team of Paulson and Geithner – well that didn’t work. They actually had facts, yes, facts to back up their actions.
Earnings across the board have been pretty stellar if not blow outs. So, please put a sock in your idiotic doomsday scenarios. You sound like an ill informed freshman in a private college. No real life experience.
This evening Obama put an end to the nonsense and fired up the country. This recovery is not only real – it’s on fire!!
One new iMaxi… sorry… iPad for Harry! Make it 10!
Selling iPads is going to boost the economy and employ millions of our Amerikan Komrades! We will bury you!
100 iPads for Hairy… It’s the year of the heavy economic bs flow!
Harry, it would be great fun to jump ahead 10 years and see what song you are singing then, lol. This past year companies cut employees and so earnings are ok. But you cannot have a growing economy when MORE people are unemployed each month, and MORE people lose their houses, and MORE banks go broke, and MORE money is created by the gov’t and spent piling up debts no one will ever be able to pay. Eat, drink, and be merry, for tomorrow we die!
Harry the fool has lost me $70 a share on GOOG so far.
Warren – in 10 years he’ll be singing the same fired-up song from the lettuce fields.
“You sound like an ill informed freshman in a private college. No real life experience.”
Pot calling the kettle black, no?