A few months ago, the insightful and engaging financial market observer, James Grant, drew a comparison between “witchcraft, on the one hand, and modern central banking, on the other.”
Grant presented this novel comparison in an address to the “Investment Decisions and Behavioral Finance” meeting at the Harvard Kennedy School.
“I won’t spend much time defining terms,” Grant began. “Witches, as you know, cast spells, make storms and fly on goats or broomsticks to diabolical nighttime rendezvouses called sabbats. Modern central bankers override the price mechanism, conjure money from thin air and undertake to boost economic growth by raising up stock prices.”
In other words, both activities rely greatly on a kind of mysticism – beginning with the notion that combining bizarre ingredients in a cauldron can work magic…and ending with the notion that mere mortals can wield supernatural powers.
Ben Bernanke’s “eye of newt” is quantitative easing (QE). According to American folklore, Bernanke casts benevolent spells, simply by tossing just the right amount of QE into the economic cauldron at just the right time.
“One might almost call it witchcraft,” Grant concludes his address.
Between Grant’s opening remarks and his conclusion, he presents one very striking, and somewhat alarming, comparison between witchcraft and central banking. Both superstitions emerged and then flourished during a time of relative enlightenment. Educated and enlightened populations embraced both beliefs.
Quoting an essay entitled, “The European Witch Craze of the 16th and 17th Centuries,” by British historian, H.R. Trevor-Roper, Grant remarked, “The belief in witches was not, ‘Trevor-Roper writes, ‘a lingering ancient superstition, only waiting to dissolve. It was a new explosive force, constantly and fearfully expanding with the passage of time…
‘Creduality in high places increased, its engines of expression were made more terrible, more victims were sacrificed to it. The years 1550-1600 were worse than the years 1500-1550, and the years 1600-1650 were worse still…If those two centuries were an age of light, we have to admit that, in one respect at least, the Dark Age was more civilized.”
After contemplating Grant’s observations, a hard-money guy or gal, couldn’t help but think of the “Dark Ages” of the gold standard, in contrast to the Enlightened Age of central banking.
During the monetary Dark Ages, the gold-backed dollar fended for itself, without the benefit of central bank wizardry.
But the Age of Monetary Enlightenment changed all that. The Federal Reserve began casting its spells 100 years ago, and the U.S. dollar has been bewitched ever since. The greenback has lost 97% of its purchasing power since the Federal Reserve came into existence.
The Fed’s beguiling wizardry continues nonetheless. Ben Bernanke concocts his bubbling brews of QE #1 through QE-infinity, while other PhDs at the Fed publish illuminating manuscripts like the recently released, “Computing Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium Models with Recursive Preferences and Stochastic Volatility.” (Thanks, Jim Grant).
Given their impressive array of charms and potions, it should come as no surprise that the wizards at the Fed believe in their own magic; the surprise is that the investing public also believes in it…and remains spellbound by the Fed’s incantations.
Just yesterday, Chairman Bernanke repeated his familiar incantation, “More QE…More QE…Whatever may be…More QE.”
The Dow Jones Industrial Average promptly rallied more than 100 points. The masses were awed by his power.
“In the current economic environment, the benefits of asset purchases, and of policy accommodation more generally, are clear,” Bernanke told the Senate Housing and Urban Affairs Committee yesterday, referring to the $85 billion of Treasury and mortgage-backed securities the Fed buys under its current quantitative easing program.
“Monetary policy is providing important support to the recovery,” the Chairman-Wizard continues, “while keeping inflation close to the [Fed's] 2% objective.”
Beguiling words, to be sure. But Bernanke’s spells may not be quite as potent as he would have us believe. The “important support to the economy” that QE provides is literally invisible.
The so-called recovery of the last four years has logged the slowest growth rate – by far – of any recovery since WWII, despite the fact that Bernanke has conducted more the $2 trillion of QE programs during that time frame.
Many are the data points that call into question the “success” of QE. For starters, U.S. GDP contracted in the final three months of 2012. Accordingly, unemployment remains stubbornly high and consumer spending stubbornly low.
Just last week, Wal-Mart’s VP of finance and logistics groaned in an internal email:
“In case you haven’t seen a sales report these days, February MTD (month-to-date) sales are a total disaster…The worst start to a month I have seen in my seven years with the company.”
The retail giant also reported that its sales are tracking very closely to what it calls the “paycheck cycle” – i.e., sales spike twice a month…on paydays.
“[This trend] speaks to a strapped consumer that lacks the confidence to spend unless they literally have cash in their pocket,” blogger, Jeff Macke, observes. “Living paycheck to paycheck isn’t something you typically see in the fourth year of an economic recovery.”
Nevertheless, very few investors exhibit any desire to consider the downside. Perhaps for good reason. Why fret over “Bubble, bubble, toil and trouble” when Chairman Bernanke provides continues helpings of “Bubble, Bubble?”
Despite Bernanke’s dubious power over the economy, the man sure knows how to conjure a stock market rally out of thin air. The Dow has soared about 250 points since he began addressing the Senate yesterday.
One might almost call it witchcraft.
Eric J. Fry, Agora Financial's Editorial Director, has been a specialist in international equities for nearly two decades. He was a professional portfolio manager for more than 10 years, specializing in international investment strategies and short-selling. Following his successes in professional money management, Mr. Fry joined the Wall Street-based publishing operations of James Grant, editor of the prestigious Grant's Interest Rate Observer. Working alongside Grant, Mr. Fry produced Grant's International and Apogee Research, institutional research products dedicated to international investment opportunities and short selling.
Mr. Fry subsequently joined Agora Inc., as Editorial Director. In this role, Mr. Fry supervises the editorial and research processes of numerous investment letters and services. Mr. Fry also publishes investment insights and commentary under his own byline as Editor of The Daily Reckoning. Mr. Fry authored the first comprehensive guide to investing internationally with American Depository Receipts. His views and investment insights have appeared in numerous publications including Time, Barron's, Wall Street Journal, International Herald Tribune, Business Week, USA Today, Los Angeles Times and Money.
This is all going to end very badly!
“I won’t spend much time defining terms,” Grant began. “Witches, as you know, cast spells, make storms and fly on goats or broomsticks to diabolical nighttime rendezvouses called sabbats.
Was this fictitious analogy really necessary? Fox just got caught pulling the same crap…we witches are not amused.
Fuck your religion too, you worthless bigot!!
You realize that there are actual witches, correct? This article is extremely offensive to actual Witches and Wiccans.
You sir are ignorant beyond words. I am a Wiccan, and this article offends me in essentially every possible way. We as witches are not evil, not mythological, not out to fuck up your day. we simply want respect, love, and to be treated as equal humans, nothing more, nothing less. So I shall suggest you either learn what the fuck you’re talking about before you write up an article about it, or don’t fucking talk about it at all. Shouldn’t be too fucking difficult for your peanut-sized mental-capacity to wrap around.
Wow, I don’t even know where to begin except to say that you just drastically maligned and defamed over a million people in America alone who are Wiccans and Witches.
Try substituting the word “Witch” with “Jew” or “Irish” or “Indian” or “Gay” and see how it sounds to you.
Do you kiss your mom with that mouth?
This is only one of the things we are talking about. There is lots more.
“If you piss off a bunch of witches, you’re going to have a bad time”
This is not going to end badly….. It means everyone is going to have to live very carefully. They are going to have to invest their savings in oil sands upgrading and oil recovery, as in northern Alberta or in the Gulf of Mexico now, for example. Or it means they are going to have to lend money to state, provincial, federal, or local governments. In other words, apparently during the zero-interest rate policy, the saver has to be willing to take-on some minimal risk to gain some yield in his/her portfolio.
Another thing to-day, people have to conserve money. For example, they have to return empty bottles into the bottle depot, not just for the good of the environment but actually for the money itself and for the important practical jobs that returning the bottles creates in the economy everywhere.
Another thing that might be changing now with Bernanke’s zero-interest rate policy is that new homes cost more money. How much older homes are going to appreciate remains to be seen, AND NEITHER NEW NOR OLD HOMES WILL APPRECIATE IF BANKS WON’T LEND WITHOUT LARGE DOWN PAYMENTS.
Finally, if the zero-interest rate policy really marks the shift to the beginning of a deflation, it still might not hurt to keep some gold in one’s safe deposit box, just in case the central bank changes its policy and abandons its zero-interest rate policy and goes back to its former ways of inflating forever.
Fry is lucky we Wiccans are peaceful people. He wold do well to learn to live by our creed “Do no harm.” Very ignorant statements. There are more of us than you know
I dont see the need to be offended. I just expect stupidity out of the mundanes, so when I find a smart one I can be pleasantly surprised. I doesn’t matter a tinkers damn what the mundanes think of us, unless they are thinking about trying to hurt us.
This is the type of negative stereotypes that persist because people speak out of ignorance. This guy obviously knows nothing about the subject of witches or wicca and yet basis his whole analogy on something he pulled out of his… hat.
“extremely offensive to actual Witches and Wiccans”?
Wow! I’ll bet Harry Potter fans the world over are miffed by all this?
Surprises me that the easily offended Dungeons and Dragons crowd spends much time on a page like this?
I’m not sure if you are being serious or not. I’m thinking maybe you are. While there are people out there who pretend to be witches, the rest of us know there is no such thing as a witch anywhere except in imaginations. I don’t think people should have to pretend truths are untrue in order to protect the fragile emotional state of people who believe in falsehood.
That is absolutely unfair. A lot of them are in the Live Action Role Play crowd as well.
Uh oh, I think he’s mad, oh no! Watch out! Ribbit, ribbit.
“Mundanes”? Is that like a “muggle”?
I’ve met loads of angry Wiccans. Give me a break. Like Islam is the “religion of peace”.
Witch? What are you some kind of clown?
Do you believe in a God? I’m not sure if you’re serious if you do. We all know that there is no such thing as a God anywhere except in your imaginations.
Maybe you should educate yourself a bit before being such a bigot.
Pingback: Joshua A. Jacobi MD
Pingback: Vehicle expenses other than gas
Pingback: plantacja lawendy
Pingback: jazda konna
Pingback: visit link
Pingback: fare soldi
Pingback: autoversicherung vergleich
Pingback: online casino
Pingback: empower network loophole
Pingback: coal miner song
Pingback: Glenn Rhee
Pingback: come giocare alle slot machine da bar gratis
Pingback: promotional gifts
Pingback: driving lessons milton keynes
Pingback: jalia parsnip
Pingback: mark mania
Pingback: click to watch
Pingback: Another Blog Title
Pingback: universal remote
Pingback: Anastacia Poirer
Pingback: Kathe Groshek
Pingback: visit the website
Pingback: otc ed pills that work
Pingback: Nellie Grinder
Pingback: Evangelina Kerkhoff
Pingback: seo los angeles
Pingback: Winfred Fie
Pingback: Kirk Galiano
Pingback: Domingo Mcclary
Pingback: best online backup
Pingback: best online data backup
Pingback: Oswaldo Levitan
Pingback: car crashes
Pingback: Mitch Cance
Pingback: Gail Seard
Pingback: charlottesville farms
Pingback: Texas wedding videographer
Pingback: deezer gratuit
Pingback: fastest way to get abs
Pingback: vigrx cheap
Pingback: ed dysfunction
Pingback: youtube partnership
Pingback: ipad cushions
Pingback: garcinia cambogia
Pingback: KM Dn155 Black
Pingback: barbour outlet
Pingback: marijuana seeds for sale
Pingback: how can you learn social media online
Pingback: Payday Loans
Pingback: Leaky Boy new single Here Kitty free download on MTV
Pingback: the best protein
Pingback: UK Karen Millen Dn155 Silver Floral Cutwork Dress Outlet
Pingback: russian car crashes
Pingback: lon rosen vancouver
Pingback: how to get your ex girlfriend back
Pingback: car crash
Pingback: social bookmarking
Pingback: lon rosen sports agent
Pingback: cool ipad mini accessories
Pingback: test and tag
Pingback: aprende tocar guitarra
Pingback: ham radio3k
Pingback: wasp extermination Orlando
Pingback: canon rebel xs camera
Pingback: search engine submission optimization
Pingback: Dating Tester
Pingback: tapped out springfield
Pingback: electrical stores
Pingback: internet marketing search engine
Pingback: moncler sale
Pingback: FFXI è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: POE Items
Pingback: FIFA 14 RMT
Pingback: DMA Portland
Pingback: Garcinia Extract
Pingback: runescape 3 gold
Pingback: FUT14 Coins
Pingback: male enhancement
Pingback: How to make wine
Pingback: learn more
Pingback: see this page
Pingback: RuneScape Power Leveling
Pingback: FF14 è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: dog poop bags
Pingback: london international school of performing arts
Pingback: click here now
Pingback: no credit check car title loans
Pingback: breaking bad season 4
Pingback: cash for cars miami
Pingback: woodwork projects
Pingback: LOTRO Gold
Pingback: Neverwinter Power Leveling
Pingback: Guild Wars 2 Power Leveling
Pingback: home for sale in Talis Park naples florida
Pingback: ãƒ‰ãƒ©ã‚´ãƒ³ãƒã‚¹ãƒˆ RMT
Pingback: How To Get Him Back Without Seeming Needy Or Desperate
Pingback: kelly osbourne weight loss diet
Pingback: diablo 3 gold
Pingback: FIFA 14 coins PS4
Pingback: ãƒ‰ãƒ©ã‚´ãƒ³ã‚¯ã‚¨ã‚¹ãƒˆX RMT
Pingback: we buy cars
Pingback: wall stickers
Pingback: MHF Zeny
Pingback: comment pirater un compte facebook
Pingback: Welcome back songs pk
Pingback: èˆžç¿”ä¼ RMT
Pingback: boundra RMT
Pingback: EverQuest Next Power Leveling
Pingback: path of exile Items
Pingback: ãƒ‰ãƒ©ã‚´ãƒ³ã‚¯ã‚¨ã‚¹ãƒˆX ã‚´ãƒ¼ãƒ«ãƒ‰
Pingback: path of exile power leveling
Pingback: woodworking projects
Pingback: World of Tanks Power Leveling
Pingback: ESO Power Leveling
Pingback: david sills jazz
Pingback: rs3 gold
Pingback: dog board
Pingback: free sesso
Pingback: niacinamide cream
Pingback: funny Pictures
Pingback: cool packs
Pingback: guild wars 2 power leveling
Pingback: FF14 RMT
Pingback: Rape Defense Law Falls Church Virginia
Pingback: PSO2 ãƒ¡ã‚»ã‚¿
Pingback: ArcheAge RMT
Pingback: james osmar
Pingback: ãƒ¬ã‚¸ã‚§ãƒ³ãƒ‰ ã‚ªãƒ– ã‚½ã‚¦ãƒ«ã‚º RMT
Pingback: FF14 ã‚®ãƒ«
Pingback: Harga Pasaran HP
Pingback: Get Unstuck
Pingback: Cladding Toowoomba
Pingback: ipad accessories bluetooth
Pingback: æˆ¦å›½ixa RMT
Pingback: tablet cushion rest
Pingback: best beat making software
Pingback: Acheter e-liquide
Pingback: Buy Hypercet Blood Pressure Formula
Pingback: Unlock iPhone Chile
Pingback: Voyance amour
Pingback: Electronic Components
Pingback: Revitol Buttocks Cream Review
Pingback: diablo 3 power leveling eu
Pingback: wooden bangles buyers in bulk in calcutta
Pingback: PSO2 RMT
Pingback: Browse Around Here
Pingback: living room furniture
Pingback: seat cushion for car
Pingback: how to make money online
Pingback: Richard Linhart Dalrymple in Durant OK
Pingback: BNS RMT
Pingback: MHF RMT
Pingback: Nanny cam
Pingback: ãƒ©ã‚¹ãƒ†ã‚£ãƒãƒ¼ãƒ„ RMT
Pingback: Diablo 3 RMT
Pingback: overnight cat sitter
Pingback: AION ã‚®ãƒ¼ãƒŠ
Pingback: marketing the web
Pingback: (PMI Certification
Pingback: PMP Certification)
Pingback: The Elder Scrolls Online Power Leveling
Pingback: How To Get Your Ex Back
Pingback: FIFA 14 Coins
Pingback: ãƒ‰ãƒ©ã‚¯ã‚¨10 RMT
Pingback: everquest next power leveling
Pingback: facebook hacker
Pingback: Mobile app developer singapore
Pingback: lunatik taktik review
Pingback: Karat Distributor
Pingback: nj criminal defense
Pingback: iherb.com coupon
Pingback: iherb discount code
Pingback: how to dunk
Pingback: Anna Belopolskaya
Pingback: weight loss la habra
Pingback: for local ac repair in houston visit airbourne
Pingback: iherb code
Pingback: web content
Pingback: Acid Reflux PLR
Today, Wayne Mulligan counts down the top 5 most profitable investments in history and discusses the one thing they all have in common... and the one "golden rule" that increases your odds of doubling or even tripling your money in the markets. Read on...
When the government pumps trillions of dollars into the economy, it's not actually printing the money. It enters as digital entries in banks across the country. It's made the system fast, responsive, and unfortunately, vulnerable. And ff this network goes down, the entire world could fall apart. Bill Bonner explains...
Debtor's prison is supposed to be illegal in the U.S., but these days it's making a comeback. Today, Alexander Tabarrok explains how a simple failure to pay court fees can start to snowball, eventually ending in jail time. And he begins by focusing a keen eye on the problems going on in Ferguson, Missouri. Read on...
People assume that markets and financial instruments have some kind of long-term average they tend to flock toward. But in reality, a handful of wild swings in various directions often skew these averages to a point where the "long-term" is not at all reliable, let along predictable. Chris Mayer has more...
The debt and leverage that Washington and Wall Street have built up over the years will eventually blow up. And when it does, it could be "worse than 2008." But there is at least one way to protect yourself. And today Dave Gonigam explains how you can get started before any of this occurs. Read on...