If GDP is telling us that the US economy is steadily improving, how come so many folks on Main Street feel so bad? Don’t they read the papers? Don’t they know the GDP is improving?
The short answer to these questions is that the GDP calculation is a fraud…or perhaps it’s a fraud wrapped in a deception.
To understand why the GDP numbers could be so good when the economy all around looks so bad, it is necessary to understand a few pertinent details of the GDP calculation. It is necessary to see just what meat and meat by-products go into this economic sausage. For one thing, GDP includes government spending…but does not SUBTRACT any of the borrowing the government does to fund its spending. And obviously, government spending is in no way a reflection of private sector economic activity.
Therefore, as Frank Shostak, an adjunct scholar of the Mises Institute, observes, “The GDP framework gives the impression that it is not the activities of individuals that produce goods and services, but something else outside these activities called the ‘economy.’ However, at no stage does the so-called ‘economy’ have a life of its own, independent of individuals. The so-called economy is a metaphor – it doesn’t exist.”
Convention tells us that the GDP framework is, more or less, a tool used to measure the size and health of this “metaphor”…ahem, the “economy.” Most often, we hear it expressed as a rate of growth – either positive or negative. And it is this widely followed number that determines when economic expansions end and recessions begin (two consecutive quarters of “negative growth.”). But GDP as a measurement is really just hogwash. It can no more calculate the health of an economy than it can tell you the time or give you a back massage.
Let us consider briefly the computation of the GDP measure. There are three main ways to calculate GDP:
1) The expenditure method2) The income method and3) The value-added method.
Theoretically, all three methods should produce the same result although, in practice, this almost never happens. For instance, when there is a large surge in public spending, as we have seen recently with the torrent of stimulus packages from governments around the world, the GDP “growth” registers most prominently in the expenditure method.
Roughly speaking, this method calculates the “size” of an economy by totaling its expenditures, minus imports. It is also the most common method employed to determine GDP. The equation looks like this:
GDP = private consumption + gross investment + government spending + (exports − imports).
To understand just how misleading the expenditure method can be, let us consider briefly the case of the Australian economy. It is widely accepted that the Aussies, under the deft stewardship of Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, had avoided entering a technical recession during the crisis from which we are now said to be “recovering.” It’s a nice story…except that it is a lie or, at best, a “one-third truth.”
Australia DID unquestionably fall into recession. It’s just a matter of definitions.
Like their American counterparts, Australian politicians pushed through a series of emergency stimulus packages, now credited with having helped the country avoid recession. Dr. Steven Kates, who lectures on economics at RMIT University in Melbourne, provided a rare dose of clarity in a recent article, published in The Australian. Dr. Kates concludes that by both the income and value-added measures, Australia comfortably satisfied the criteria for a technical recession.
“The income series… indicates a pretty minimal year all round,” Dr. Kates explains. “Both the September and December 2008 quarters showed an actual fall in the level of output, the very definition of a technical recession. Over the year, the level of GDP has fallen 0.4 per cent, by no means as bad as elsewhere, but more in keeping with the general experience across the economy.
“The third measure shows the changes in GDP according to the production-based data,” Kates continues. “Here, too, [in the value added, or, production series] we have the ingredients for a technical recession, with an actual reduction in the level of output in both December 2008 and March 2009. Across the year, GDP has fallen by 0.7 per cent.
“While the stimulus package appears to have been able to distort one of the three sets of national accounting measures we use,” Dr. Kates concluded, “beneath it all the Australian economy, in keeping with the rest of the developed world, has gone through a recessionary phase from which it is only now beginning to emerge.”
Therefore, the only way the Australian government could claim that it had “avoided” a recession was by utilizing the expenditure method, or by averaging all three measures of GDP together. Here we see that unprecedented government stimulus spending propped up the expenditure metric, much like a steroid injection might help prop up a cheating athlete. Not only is stimulus spending an unsustainable and deceptive scam, measuring it as a “+” under the expenditure GDP calculation separates further the reality individuals experience from the fantasy their governments serve up to them.
As the Australian example shows, this methodology simply ignores the fact that government spending is not true production at all because it is debt financed. Government spending, therefore, should really only be government spending, LESS government borrowing.
You see how misleading this measurement can be, especially when huge sums of debt-financed stimulus must be taken into account. Sound familiar?
Murray Rothbard, the legendary Austrian economist, elaborated further when he proposed his alternative measures: Gross Private Product (GPP) and Private Product Remaining (PPR).
Rothbard defines the former as “gross national product less income originating in government and government enterprises.” PPR is GPP less the higher of government expenditures and tax revenues plus interest received. Rothbard argues that because government output is “financed coercively” (i.e., by taxation), it is unclear what – if any – market value may be ascribed to the end product. Simply put, both measures place government “production” where it belongs: in the “opportunity cost” pile.
If free market participants did not deem it worth their while to buy something in the first place, why should it be considered a net positive when the government uses their money (or China’s) to buy it on their behalf? This case may be brought against the “cash for clunkers” program, the $8,000 credit for homebuyers and impending “cash for anything” programs currently finding their way through the special-interest-greased halls of Congress as we write. Indeed, the entire bailout and stimulus programs fall squarely into the opportunity cost pile. But that’s not how those trillions are calculated using conventional GDP metrics.
Measure it how you will, dear reader; true economic progress is forged not in the crucibles of debt or coercion, but from the honest toil of individuals seeking to better their own lot, unhindered from the government’s long, strangulating reach. No nation can spend its way out of recession…no matter what the official GDP numbers may imply.
Joel Bowman,for The Daily Reckoning
Joel Bowman is a contributor to The Daily Reckoning. After completing his degree in media communications and journalism in his home country of Australia, Joel moved to Baltimore to join the Agora Financial team. His keen interest in travel and macroeconomics first took him to New York where he regularly reported from Wall Street, and he now writes from and lives all over the world.
GDP is so fundamentally a fraud by it’s core definition that it’s mind boggling that it’s even used.
Essentially take the national equivalent of a business’ financial cash flow statement, then for every cash flow type take the absolute value, and then sum all the values. It’s no wonder you can have “good economic growth” without actually creating anything or any actual productivity. It’s mathematically nonsensical to its core. Mind you GNP is only slightly less insane.
And what is the excuse for hand-waving GDP? We don’t know how to measure anything else and/or it’s too complicated (undemocratic?) to label specific cash flows as positive or negative, and we can presume that any cash flow contribute perfectly equivalent value. All of these are nonsense – if a nation has the value of self-preservation, dedication to its citizens and general sustainability, it is simple enough to allocate some flows as positive or negative in terms of national worth and value. We can’t seem to do that so we just “look under the streetlight where the light is better” rather than where the value really is.
It is a fact that accounting can easily hide the real state of any business and so it is with any country – the problem is that nowhere can one seriously believe that creating additional debt will solve any problems, unless one intends intentionally to renage on the debt – does that thought worry anyone out there?
How does one create something out of nothing? – by fiddling the books?
Naturally this is the new way!
Who are we kidding?
Pingback: plantacja lawendy
Pingback: download free slot machine bar
Pingback: non-prescription supplements
Pingback: how to win the lottery books click through the up coming web page
Pingback: stromanbieter vergleich
Pingback: european roulette gold free play
Pingback: Zalando Gutschein
Pingback: people name
Pingback: free people search
Pingback: buy ageless male
Pingback: lyric music video
Pingback: RKXeroFlGi RKXeroFlGi
Pingback: slot machine bar
Pingback: App Builder Software
Pingback: driving lesson in milton keynes
Pingback: falzkarte drucken
Pingback: Forestville EC
Pingback: heidi montag cirugias
Pingback: Jasa SEO
Pingback: used shot peening equipment
Pingback: need money fast no credit check
Pingback: Elenore Neally
Pingback: tworzenie stron www
Pingback: online casino free bonus ohne einzahlung
Pingback: Check This
Pingback: Pulau Tidung
Pingback: international payment processing
Pingback: wasp control sheffield
Pingback: online natural healing courses
Pingback: pearl gold bracelet
Pingback: vivere vienna
Pingback: duffle travel bags
Pingback: seo orange county ca
Pingback: mobile marketing magazine awards
Pingback: standard coffee service
Pingback: paris hilton surgery
Pingback: fishing key west
Pingback: Thu Dunneback
Pingback: tekkit server list
Pingback: entertainment news
Pingback: Bobby Shearing
Pingback: beylikdüzü escort
Pingback: Click that
Pingback: Susan Goodell MFT
Pingback: view posters article
Pingback: have a peek at these guys
Pingback: debt forgiveness tax ustaxshield
Pingback: Richard Wan
Pingback: kurt rambis wikipedia
Pingback: rosland capital website
Pingback: EASWAR ELUMALAI
Pingback: Upfront Reputations Reviews
Pingback: Wilton Basquez
Pingback: Jess Kenealy
Pingback: Tony Placek
Pingback: Jacquie Polian
Pingback: Jonas Kesson
Pingback: Krystal Cromuel
Pingback: Eliseo Smutnick
Pingback: Otha Cuffari
Pingback: Seymour Relyea
Pingback: Carol Moening
Pingback: paintless dent repair training for pdr
Pingback: ayman khawaja
Pingback: Emil Primes
Pingback: Thad Olivia
Pingback: Mark Theophilus
Pingback: Anjanette Fegaro
Pingback: Sherika Oliven
Pingback: Russel Borgos
Pingback: Andre Padillia
Pingback: matthew browndorf
Pingback: Marinda Konek
Pingback: Wesley Gorby
Pingback: Barney Obas
Pingback: Reginald Kagarise
Pingback: Arleen Eatough
Pingback: David Kaleohano
Pingback: Gerard Carbajal
Pingback: matthew browndorf antitrust
Pingback: Lawerence Kupec
Pingback: gestion integral de servicios
Pingback: upfront reputations reviews
Pingback: real estate law center pc
Pingback: Facebook Buy Likes
Pingback: Facebook Real Like
Pingback: get facebook photo likes
Pingback: great job
Pingback: how to create an android app
Pingback: work at home moms
Pingback: nikon dslr underwater housing
Pingback: pure green coffee bean extract reviews
Pingback: buy likes
Pingback: facebook likes
Pingback: buy usa facebook likes
Pingback: social bookmarking
Pingback: umek at tomorrowland
Pingback: electronic cigarette free trial offer
Pingback: cheap twitter followers
Pingback: buy followers on twitter
Pingback: twitter followers cheap
Pingback: buy 200 twitter followers
Pingback: web marketing experts
Pingback: buy soundcloud followers
Pingback: visitors to my site
Pingback: lose weight fast
Pingback: used transmissions online
Pingback: get free facebook likes
Pingback: house energy rating
Pingback: cheap car rental nice france
Pingback: Mexico Weather
Pingback: data recovery company singapore
Pingback: web development
Pingback: How To Conceive A Girl
Pingback: electronic cigarettes free trial
Pingback: Joshua A Jacobi
Pingback: paintless dent repair
Pingback: co to jest aspartam
Pingback: online casino echtgeld bonus ohne einzahlung
Pingback: to lose weight
Pingback: Лучшие форекс брокеры
Pingback: dukan diet attack phase vinegar
Pingback: special needs travel
Pingback: Drago De Silver
Pingback: pantalones de yoga
Pingback: montar negocio
Pingback: car body repairs in leeds
Pingback: AUTO IMPORTEREN
Pingback: PS3 Trophy Service
Pingback: green tea
Pingback: curar las hemorroides
Pingback: casino ohne einzahlung
Pingback: kate middleton before and after
Pingback: phen diet pills
Pingback: had me going
Pingback: Wake up now
Pingback: linkedin free trial
Pingback: click here
Pingback: Divorce Attorney Mesa AZ
Pingback: eq2 power leveling
Pingback: view more
Pingback: RaiderZ GP
Pingback: my website
Pingback: How to make a camera slider
Pingback: runescape power leveling
Pingback: JT Foxx
Pingback: fifa 14 ultimate team coins ps3
Pingback: How to Build Your Lead List
Pingback: restaurant in navan
Pingback: diablo 3 power leveling
Pingback: laundry service singapore
Pingback: jeremy geffen los angeles
Pingback: click here to download
Pingback: archeage gold
Pingback: Elder Scrolls Online Power Leveling
Pingback: lotro power leveling
Pingback: runescape 3 gold
Pingback: diablo 3 gold hardcore eu
Pingback: the secret world power leveling
Pingback: cloud web service
Pingback: swtor credits
Pingback: how to create azure account with no credit card
Pingback: centurion d5 gate motor
Pingback: archeage power leveling
Pingback: runescape 3 power leveling
Pingback: diablo 3 gold asia
Pingback: marvel hero power leveling
Pingback: runescape 2007 power leveling
Pingback: carbon marcky
Pingback: $2 to your account for free
Pingback: wow gold
Pingback: poe power leveling
Pingback: marko man
Pingback: universal remote
Pingback: AION Power Leveling
Pingback: find a babysitter
Pingback: Age of WuLin Liang
Pingback: makia julpo
Pingback: KAL Online Geon
Pingback: PR9 Backlinks for $1
Pingback: linear algebra help
Pingback: Ardina Alfonso
Pingback: dialysis lawsuit
Pingback: GranuFlo heart attack
Pingback: keith jones ace parking
Pingback: free blog no deposit games.com
Pingback: boost socials
Pingback: empower network review
Pingback: how do i catch him cheating
Pingback: Furniture Home Improvement Ideas
Pingback: Reputable Source
Pingback: buy instagram followers
Pingback: Blue Greenish Home Improvement
Pingback: Asbestos removal contractors glasgow
Pingback: Navigate Here
Pingback: ï»¿FF11 è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: nero essential mix free download Here
Pingback: ãƒ©ã‚°ãƒŠãƒã‚¯ã‚ªãƒ³ãƒ©ã‚¤ãƒ³ è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: Is Social Media Affecting Your Credibility
Pingback: ãƒ¬ã‚¸ã‚§ãƒ³ãƒ‰ ã‚ªãƒ– ã‚½ã‚¦ãƒ«ã‚º è‚²æˆä»£è¡Œ
Pingback: memory foam mattress topper
Pingback: Twitter Followers for $1
Pingback: Why Not Try Here
Pingback: mark mania
Pingback: Promote to 16 Million Real People
Pingback: LEGO Marvel Super Heroes Movie
Pingback: chase bank logon
Pingback: New GDP
Pingback: Real Estate Law Center Complaints
Today, Ray tells you how to profit from curing cancer.
The US in the midst of an energy revolution, but it hasn't come easily. It's been a long time in the making, and the only reason it's happening is because of technological breakthroughs in oil production. Today, Ray Blanco explains why the next step in this energy revolution is improving seismic technology. Read on...
Social media stocks have been beaten and left for dead since investors started selling in September. But are they poised to take a ride on the current end-of-year rally train? Greg Guenthner explains why, despite looking bruised and bloodied, you shouldn't count out social media just yet. Read on...
Thanks to America's shale boom, there has been plenty of "black gold" unleashed on the market as of late. But as that story progress, there's also a "new gold" that investors may be overlooking... and it is vitally important to the fracking process and the production of new oil wells. Matt Insley explains...
It's interesting to listen to politicians' assessment of the U.S. government. Many believe it's a functional system of "self-government" that gives back as much as citizens are willing to put into it. Of course, as Sheldon Richman explains, U.S. citizens do not actually govern themselves, but are rather ruled by those who suggest they do. Read on...
Former Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan was asked recently on Bloomberg TV and scoffed at Bitcoin.