The commercial real estate crisis may be the most anticipated crisis in history. But just because it’s widely anticipated doesn’t mean that the crisis won’t be destructive for REIT shares. Since most REITs are richly valued, the slow-moving commercial real estate crisis will ensure that future returns disappoint.
Consider the valuation of REITs versus the S&P 500, which itself is overvalued. Despite being 25% below its late 2007 peak, the US stock market – measured by the S&P 500 index – is very expensive. The “Shiller P/E ratio,” developed by Yale professor Robert Shiller, measures the S&P 500 against the average S&P 500 earnings over the previous 10 years, adjusted for inflation. It’s a much more robust measure of valuation, considering the fluctuation of corporate earnings, and the fact that after bubbles, much of the earnings booked during the boom are written off during the bust. Consider that the earnings booked by Citigroup and other big banks near the peak of the bubble were largely written off during the bust. Therefore, a 10-year average of earnings is a better indicator of true earnings.
The Shiller P/E ratio for the S&P 500 Index is now 21 – up dramatically from 13 at the March 2009 lows. This 21 P/E is higher than at almost any point in stock market history, outside of the late 1920s bubble, the late 1990s bubble, and the market peak in 2007. The S&P 500 is overvalued based on the Shiller P/E, but corporate earnings are supposedly going to soar in 2010, right? Well, even if you believe the optimistic 2010 estimates, the market is still more than fully valued on that metric.
Commercial real estate – and the REITs that hold commercial properties – began to deflate rapidly in late 2008. But the Fed stepped in with bailout funds and easy money to halt the deflation…and even pumped the bubble back up a bit. The nearby chart shows the results of the Fed’s handwork. REITs of all shapes and sizes more than doubled off the stock market lows of last March, while the Bloomberg Hotel REIT Index more than tripled. (We’ll come back to this chart a little later).
This rally has the look and feel of a dead-cat bounce, which means that it provides an attractive short-selling entry point.
REITs soared as the bubble inflated from 2000-2007, then crashed when the bubble popped in 2008 and early 2009, and then launched a dead cat bounce when the Fed flooded the system in mid-2009 with massive injections of liquidity and cheap credit. Now REITs are priced at bubble valuations – valuations that bear little resemblance to economic reality.
This bounce has postponed a healthy purge of assets in which old capital invested by foolish speculators during the bubble would have been wiped out – clearing the way for new owners to assume title to real estate at reasonable prices. When central banks prop up deflating bubbles with super-easy bailout cash, the bubble investors don’t liquidate their overly inflated assets. They hang on and hope for a turnaround.
But bubbles always deflate…always. Government intervention merely muffles the hissing sound for a while. This story played out in the Japanese real estate bubble that peaked in 1990, and it’s happening with the US commercial real estate bubble that peaked in 2007. Capital becomes trapped in a dead asset class, thereby stretching the bubble’s resolution out over decades.
Toward the end of 2009, it became clear that “extend and pretend” had become the official policy at most banks that hold commercial mortgages. We won’t see a cleansing flush of hundreds of billions in underwater properties changing hands to new owners. Instead, properties will be dribbled out of the foreclosure pipeline at a slow pace. This measured pace of foreclosures will add to the chronic glut of property that will be quickly listed for sale into any bounce in demand.
Some of the best short-selling opportunities in the REIT sector may be in the hotel REIT sub-sector.
It’s not a stretch to expect the hotel business will be ugly for a long time. Corporate and leisure travel is in the midst of a depression. And leveraged hotel owners built or acquired too many hotels near the peak of the commercial real estate bubble.
Now many hotel owners are desperate to generate cash in order to pay down debt and retain titles to properties. Some are slashing nightly room rates below break-even levels. You know from the growth of Internet hotel booking services just how much more competitive and transparent hotel pricing has become over the past decade. Unless competitors are willing to match the pricing of the most desperate hotel owners, healthier competitors will suffer lower occupancy.
Some levered hotel owners, like Sunstone Hotel Investors, are abandoning their equity in some properties to salvage others. In the fourth quarter of 2009, Sunstone defaulted on several nonrecourse mortgages held against 13 of its properties and turned the title over to its lenders. Sunstone calls this a “deed-back,” but it’s really a strategic default.
Sunstone’s lenders will probably keep and operate the hotels, rather than dump them at a distressed price. The behavior of Sunstone and its lenders shows how many hotel owners and lenders are putting off the necessary liquidation of underwater properties with bloated cost structures. The industry still needs to make more progress on downsizing, slashing operating costs, shrinking mortgage sizes, and lowering room rates to match demand. Until it does, the industry’s returns on capital will not consistently exceed its cost of capital.
Hotel REITs are highly sensitive to perceptions about the near-term health of the hotel business. Trends in occupancy and room rates shape perceptions about earnings. Hotel REITs own portfolios of hotels and outsource the management to companies like Marriott for a fee.
Because of the relatively fixed costs of paying management companies a fee for operating hotels, Hotel REITs operate with high operating leverage: A 20–30% decline in revenues can translate into a 50–75% decline in operating income. Also, unlike offices or retail REITs with sticky long-term leases, the cash flow for hotel REITs adjusts quickly to changing conditions on a day-by-day basis.
Over the past nine months, hotel REITs have soared on the perception that corporate and leisure travel will rebound strongly in 2010 and 2011. Analysts have forecast a sharp rebound in earnings.
But I’m not buying it. In fact, I’m selling it.
Dan Amossfor The Daily Reckoning
Dan Amoss, CFA, is a student of the Austrian school of economics, a discipline that he uses to identify imbalances in specific sectors of the market. He tracks aggressive accounting and other red flags that the market typically misses. Amoss is a Maryland native, a graduate of Loyola University Maryland, and earned his CFA charter in 2005. In spring 2008, he recommended Lehman Brothers puts, advising readers to hold the position as the stock fell from $45 to $12. Amoss is our macro strategist and guardian of The 5 Min. Forecast PRO.
Panopticon goggles? Severe market panic in 2018? Gold confiscation by 2020? Jim Rickards' shocking thought-piece in the spirit of A Brave New World or 1984. Click to see how markets, economics, your money, gold, privacy, wealth building and more look a decade from now in the year 2024...
I believe we are in the midst of one of the greatest profit opportunities you’re ever going to see in your lifetime. Stop listening to what the government is telling you. Turn off CNN. Forget what you see on the news. And for God’s sake, forget about the market crashing. Right now, we are in the early innings of the greatest profit opportunities of the 21st century. A biotech boom that’s about to hit epic proportions thanks to Ebola. If I’m right, we are going to see Ebola in New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco and Miami. And when this happens, every single stock that has anything to do with Ebola is going to soar. Let me explain to you how I believe this huge Ebola bubble is going to unfold.
Right now we’re seeing a surge of strength in the U.S. dollar, as the bottom falls out of our competitors’ currencies, and Jim Grant has the best analysis of what it means for investors. For one, it means the Federal Reserve can’t keep interest rates low forever. And mainstream investors may be very surprised when the Fed gives in…
Another one of Wall Street’s broken forecasts has plopped a new trade in your lap. If you’re listening to the lunatics on the financial news, you’re hearing that there’s no hope for the markets. Just get rid of your stocks and pound sand. Better safe than sorry—none of these talking heads want to get bullish on anything right now because they’re afraid to look like an idiot if the market keeps dropping. For them, selling stocks now is your only chance to make it to the end of the year without pawning the family cat to buy Christmas presents. Can the market survive? Greg Guenthner explains…
Breakthrough technologies can hold the most undiscovered money-making potential. What we’ve accomplished in a quarter century with cancer research could make you serious money and save countless lives. Ray Blanco has more on this ground breaking story...
On Oct. 6, 2014, Jim Rickards was interviewed by Bloomberg TV for his thoughts on gold, currency manipulation and the overall strength of the global economy. Watch the entire interview for yourself, right here...