Deception in the financial markets is not always costly, but it is rarely remunerative. Investors cannot afford to ignore this tendency.
Recent disclosures from the Federal Reserve reveal that honesty was one of the earliest casualties of the 2008 financial crisis. These disclosures contain a number of juicy tidbits, like the fact that Goldman Sachs received tens of billions of dollars in direct and indirect succor from the Fed.
Thanks to these spectacularly large taxpayer-funded bailouts, Goldman was able to continue “doing God’s Work” – as CEO Lloyd Blankfein infamously remarked – like the work of producing billion-dollar trading profits without ever suffering a single day of losses.
Thanks to the Fed’s massive, undisclosed assistance, Goldman Sachs managed to project an image of financial well-being, even while accessing tens of billions of dollars of direct assistance from the Federal Reserve.
By repaying its TARP loan, for example, Goldman wriggled out from under the nettlesome compensation limits imposed by TARP, while also conveying an image of financial strength. But this “strength” was illusory. Goldman repaid the TARP loans with funds it procured days earlier from the Federal Reserve. Then, over the ensuing months, Goldman recapitalized its balance sheet by selling tens of billions of dollars of mortgage-backed securities to the Fed.
And the public never knew anything about these activities until two weeks ago, when the Fed was forced to reveal them.
In a free-market economy, certain precepts seem fundamental…and essential:
1) Taxpayers have a right to know who’s spending their money.2) Dollar-holders have a right to know who’s debasing their money.3) Investors have a right to know who’s cheating them out of their money…by hiding the truth.
All three camps have a very large and legitimate bone to pick with the Fed’s secret bailouts of 2008 and 2009. But let’s consider only the case of the deceived investor…
Secret bailouts do not merely benefit recipients; they also deceive investors into mistaking fantasy for fact. Such deceptions often punish honest investors, like the honest investors who sold short the shares of insolvent financial institutions early in 2009.
Some of these investors had done enough homework to understand that no private-market remedy could ride to the rescue of certain financial firms. Therefore, these investors sold short the shares of certain ailing institutions and waited for nature to take its course. But the course that nature would take would be shockingly unnatural. We now know why. The Federal Reserve altered the course of nature, and did so without telling anyone.
Many of the investors who sold short ailing financial firms in 2009 were alert to the possibility that bailouts by the Federal Reserve could change the calculus. In other words, the Fed could make the bearish case less bearish…at least temporarily. Therefore, many of these investors studied the Federal Reserve’s disclosures, as well as corporate press releases, in order to quantify the Fed’s influence.
Based on all available public disclosures, the story remained fairly grim into the spring of 2009. Accordingly, the short interest – i.e., number of shares sold short – on Goldman Sachs common stock hit a record 16.3 million shares on May 15, 2009 – about 3.3% of the public float. But over the ensuing six months, Goldman’s stock soared more than 30% – producing roughly $500 million in losses for those investors who had sold short its stock. Not surprisingly, the total short interest during that timeframe plummeted to less than 6 million shares, as short-sellers closed out their losing positions.
Was it just bad luck? Or was something more nefarious at work here?
Let the reader decide. But before deciding, let the reader carefully examine the chart below, while also carefully considering a selection of public announcements from Goldman Sachs during this timeframe.
Based upon contemporaneous public disclosures, Goldman Sachs was “forced” by the Federal Reserve to accept a $10 billion loan from the TARP facility in October 2008. But Goldman’s top officers repeatedly – and very publically – bristled under the compensation limits the TARP loan imposed.
Therefore, as early as February 5, 2009, Goldman’s chief financial officer, David Viniar, remarked, “Operating our business without the government capital would be an easier thing to do. We’d be under less scrutiny…” And on February 11, 2009, CEO Blankfein magnanimously remarked, “We look forward to paying back the government’s investment so that money can be used elsewhere to support our economy.”
But at that exact moment, we now know, Goldman was operating its business with at least $25 billion of undisclosed “government capital.”
In April, 2009, The Wall Street Journal observed, “Goldman Sachs group Inc., frustrated at federally mandated pay caps, has been plotting for months to get out from under the government’s thumb… Goldman’s managers have a big incentive to escape the state’s clutches. Last year, 953 Goldman employees – nearly one in 30 – were paid in excess of $1 million apiece… But tight federal restrictions connected to the financial-sector bailout have severely crimp the Wall Street firm’s ability to offer such lavish pay this year.”
On May 7, 2009, a Goldman press release states: “We are pleased that the Federal Reserve’s Supervisory Capital Assessment Program has been completed… With respect to Goldman Sachs, the tests determined that the firm does not require further capital… We will soon repay the government’s investment from the TARP’s Capital Purchase Program.”
On June 17, 2009, Goldman finally got its wish, thanks to some timely, undisclosed assistance from the Federal Reserve. Goldman repaid its $10 billion TARP loan. But just six days before this announcement, Goldman sold $11 billion of MBS to the Fed. In other words, Goldman “repaid” the Treasury by secretly selling illiquid assets to the Fed.
One month later, Goldman’s CEO Lloyd Blankfein beamed, “We are grateful for the government efforts and are pleased that [the monies we repaid] can be used by the government to revitalize the economy, a priority in which we all have a common stake.”
As it turns out, the government continued to “revitalize” that small sliver of the economy known as Goldman Sachs. During the three months following Goldman’s re-payment of its $10 billion TARP loan, the Fed purchased $27 billion of MBS from Goldman. In all, the Fed would purchase more than $100 billion of MBS from Goldman during the 12 months that followed Goldman’s TARP re-payment.
Did private investors not have the right to know that the Federal Reserve was secretly recapitalizing Goldman’s balance sheet during this period? Did they not deserve to know that the Fed’s MBS buying was producing Goldman’s “perfect” trading record during this timeframe?
Yes, would seem to be the obvious answer.
“There’s a saying in poker: If you don’t know who the patsy is at the table, it’s you,” observes Henry Blodget, the once and again stock market analyst, “Next time you feel like bellying up to the Wall Street poker table, therefore, ask yourself again who the sucker is.”
To be continued…
Eric Fryfor The Daily Reckoning
Eric J. Fry, Agora Financial's Editorial Director, has been a specialist in international equities for nearly two decades. He was a professional portfolio manager for more than 10 years, specializing in international investment strategies and short-selling. Following his successes in professional money management, Mr. Fry joined the Wall Street-based publishing operations of James Grant, editor of the prestigious Grant's Interest Rate Observer. Working alongside Grant, Mr. Fry produced Grant's International and Apogee Research, institutional research products dedicated to international investment opportunities and short selling.
Mr. Fry subsequently joined Agora Inc., as Editorial Director. In this role, Mr. Fry supervises the editorial and research processes of numerous investment letters and services. Mr. Fry also publishes investment insights and commentary under his own byline as Editor of The Daily Reckoning. Mr. Fry authored the first comprehensive guide to investing internationally with American Depository Receipts. His views and investment insights have appeared in numerous publications including Time, Barron's, Wall Street Journal, International Herald Tribune, Business Week, USA Today, Los Angeles Times and Money.
if rubin, clinton, and a paid-off congress hadn’t gutted Glass-Steagall [which was DESIGNED to prevent EXACTLY this], and if the moronic Supremes hadn’t given these SOB’s everything they ever wanted, including George Bush II,…
…well, friends, NONE of this would have happened.
but they did, and it did.
…To Be Continued…INDEED!!!
Great work Eric, keep it up. Please God we get to see these bastards swing one day.
The sad thing is that this revelation is not being given more attention in the mainstream press
…And the smaller banks get a competitively disadvantaged because of the Fed while the taxpayers are deceived and plundered.
Ben Bernanke is not crying, End the Fed. Start by raising awareness by marking your dollars with END THE FED over the pyramid. That bill will circulate 18 months on an average.
Pingback: jazda konna
Pingback: plantacja lawendy
Pingback: walking dead game episodes
Pingback: mobile app software
Pingback: click here
Pingback: shoulder diagram
Pingback: learn more
Pingback: empower network review
Pingback: buy ageless male
Pingback: Daryl Dixon
Pingback: home inspection in the bronx
Pingback: americas got talent
Pingback: power supply 24v dc
Pingback: flights to for
Pingback: find out more
Pingback: skin tag away
Pingback: raspberry ketone supplement
Pingback: seguros en zapopan
Pingback: pure green coffee bean
Pingback: this website
Pingback: how to get rid of warts
Pingback: removing warts
Pingback: small business marketing ideas
Pingback: horror films
Pingback: hermanas de kim kardashian
Pingback: eiza gonzalez cirugia
Pingback: los angeles cardiologists
Pingback: dui attorney Miami
Pingback: How To Conceive A Girl
Pingback: kitchen countertops
Pingback: kurs zlota
Pingback: bf4 forum
Pingback: ?wietny blog
Pingback: this hyperlink
Pingback: buy hcg online
Pingback: bancos mexico
Pingback: weather tijuana
Pingback: bs-qp.com angielski
Pingback: Conceiving A Girl
Pingback: paintless dent repair
Pingback: kim kardashian senos
Pingback: pure garcinia cambogia extract reviews
Pingback: electric cigarettes offer
Pingback: mobile casino ohne einzahlung
Pingback: business ideas for beginners
Pingback: divergente casting
Pingback: recuperar a tu ex
Pingback: ashley judd before and after
Pingback: slot machine gratis
Pingback: order flowers belarus
Pingback: joshua jacobi
Pingback: get rid scars
Pingback: carbon marcky
Pingback: marko man
Pingback: universal remote
Pingback: basic algebra help
Pingback: makia julpo
Pingback: potty training
Pingback: Alternative Pain Relief
Pingback: gre math help
Pingback: Da Vinci robot lawsuit
Pingback: vaginal mesh lawsuit
Pingback: praxis 0061 dvds
Pingback: Payday Loans Columbus
Pingback: purchase naltrexone
Pingback: buy facebook likes
Pingback: buy real estate
Pingback: Asbestos removal contractors glasgow
Pingback: bicycle team building
Pingback: Brazilian BW Closure 14inch Cl-BW-14 | Hair Extensions CutieBlush
Pingback: sell clothing for cash
Pingback: Ocean King Manuel Antonio Catamaran
Pingback: zimox antibiotico bambini effetti collaterali Here
Pingback: collectible figurines
Pingback: free slotomania coins
Pingback: call of duty ghosts keygen
Pingback: write my essay
Pingback: Buy Followers
Pingback: jalia parsnip
Pingback: buy tumblr followers
Pingback: Wholesale Motorcycle and Scooter Tires
Pingback: water softener san antonio water softeners
Pingback: Try These Guys Out
Pingback: mark mania
Pingback: LEGO Marvel Super Heroes Movie
Pingback: chase online
Pingback: Facebook Marketing
Pingback: da Vinci hysterectomy
Pingback: click to view
Pingback: Sterling Silver 925 Crow Heart Diamond Cross punk rock accessories Necklace
Pingback: bad credit business loans
Pingback: epson stylus pro 3880
Pingback: Time and temperature controlled shipments conference 2014
Pingback: icon book
Pingback: vermont deals packages
Pingback: Adolph Crest
Pingback: Insurance Money Information
Pingback: РљР°Рє 2РЅРёРґРµР»СЋ РґРµСЂР¶Р°С‚ РґРёРµС‚Р° ... РљР°Рє РїРѕС…СѓРґРµС‚СЊ РїР°СЂРЅСЋ РІ Р±РµРґСЂР°С… ... Reoscoutulex.xpg.com.br
Pingback: Click Here
Pingback: handy orten
Pingback: top ppd site
Pingback: click this link here now
Pingback: handy orten kostenlos
Pingback: Joseph Dahill
Pingback: Charley Wollert
Pingback: otc ed pills walmart
Pingback: Marcella Hemken
Pingback: Eddie Dolgas
While 2013 has been a very good year for the markets, in general, the rally has come with its fair share of skeptics. Of course, they won't stay skeptics forever. And as Greg Guenthner explains, by the time your neighbor decides to get in on the action, you'll want to make sure you're ahead of him. Read on....
It's no secret that the Fed loves to print money. With "QE" this and "stimulus package" that, it's no wonder the dollar's purchasing power has been in steady decline for over 100 years. But is all this Fed money printing inflationary? And is gold really the best way to hedge against it? Chris Mayer explains...
"There are two sides to every coin," as the saying goes. And nowhere is that phrase more apt than in matters of money, especially as regards the U.S. Federal Reserve. Today, Mark Spitznagel squares off against none other than Paul Krugman to discuss that very topic. What follows is sublime entertainment. Read on...
Like it or not, size does matter. But contrary to a popular saying, bigger is not always better. Especially when it comes to the size of the state. Marc Faber explains why a world of smaller states might function better than one dominated by excessively large "superpowers." Read on...
Pope Francis recently warned people to beware the "tyranny" of capitalism. Hmmm... Would that be true capitalism and trust in free enterprise? Or the crony capitalism we're currently saddled with? Bill Bonner explains why, even though capitalism is easily corrupted by the capitalists, that doesn't necessarily mean it is a bum creed. Read on...
The average postwar U.S. expansion has lasted 58 months. In the midst of major policy dislocation in Congress and at the Fed, we are at month 52 of the current expansion, which began in June 2009. But we are running out of time – and luck.
As long as markets exist, there will people who try to predict where they are headed. Of course, no one can know for sure. And as Greg Guenthner explains, their prognostications can sometimes do more harm than good. Read on...