Joel Bowman

Reporting from Buenos Aires, Argentina…

“…it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness…”
    ~ C. Dickens, 1859.

When we hear people talk about the “tale of two economies,” we expect to find them referring to the Wall Street vs. Main Street match up. An important one, to be sure. Or maybe they’re comparing the economies of two different countries or regions; one healthy, the other moribund. The “developed vs. developing” comparison, for example, is a common one. Or maybe it’s private vs. public, that raging debate between the forces of capitalistic enterprise and socialistic control. The main problem with the latter being, as history has shown, that you eventually run out of the former.

All of these are, in their own context, worthy topics for discussion. We’ve visited them many times before in these very pages, and will likely do so again.

But what about the economy nobody talks about? That giant, $10 trillion economy currently employing half of all the workers in the world? It’s unregulated, unlicensed, untaxed and, largely, unnoticed by the mainstream press. We touched on this earlier in the week. More below…but first, the markets…

Investors would have done well to go fishing yesterday. Stocks were flat as a mill pond, ending the session more or less where they began. The major indexes in the U.S. are sitting pretty around a 5-month high. As Fellow Reckoners know, the world has been saved by central bankers, politicians and Ivy League geniuses. In the frightful days of 2008, we were told the global economy was teetering on the “edge of the abyss.” If we didn’t let these brave men and women do “whatever is necessary,” we…gulp… “might not have an economy in the morning.” Luckily, the aforementioned heroes and heroines filled in that abyss with trillions of dollars worth of paper money. So we’re all good. Nothing to worry about there. Hmm…

Alrighty then, moving on…

Gold, like stocks, barely budged yesterday. Last we looked, an ounce traded for roughly 1,640 government-issued, $1 I.O.U.s. As usual, we favor trading the government’s liability notes for the Midas metal, which, contrarily, represents the liability of no man (or thieving, politicking collection thereof).

Crude oil, meanwhile, lost about a buck a barrel. Nothing major in the news between Iran and the U.S. crossed our desk, not that we were looking very closely. No, the war drums were apparently between beats yesterday. If the whole spat fizzles out tomorrow (doubtful), we expect prices to continue tracing a long, steady path higher in accordance with unfolding supply/demand dynamics. But if the Strait of Hormuz gets choked off by a sudden burst of chest-thumping misadventurism (from either side), we won’t be expecting a miraculous, military-issued Heimlich Maneuver to restore vital supply lines overnight. Prices will likely skyrocket.

So that’s what’s up with the “seen” market. Now back to the “unseen,” the market Robert Neuwirth, author of the book Stealth of Nations: The Global Rise of the Informal Economy, refers to as “System D.” (We provided a brief intro to this in Tuesday’s column.)

In a non regulation-sized nutshell, System D refers to the world’s unregulated, non state-sanctioned economy. And it is, in many ways, where the real action is. One of our Fellow Reckoners, responding to the above introduction, offered the following observations:

“Subcontractors work for cash. This lessens taxes, workmen’s comp, insurance, and withholding costs. Many shops run cash sales without sales taxes, like camera shops at the wharves in San Francisco. Farmers’ markets sell food without overhead or taxes. This will all be increasing geometrically…”

To be sure, this is the real wild west. A kind of frontier market where innovation flourishes and the natural, evolutionary forces of creative destruction are left to sheriff the town, themselves ungoverned by the arbitrary whim of world-improvers and their insufferable ilk. As such, the system is not without its failures. But nor is it without allure. Continues our reader:

“More and more people will be tempted to take the risk of government action against them, because it is better than starving, and the more people who work outside the system, the harder it will be for the government to force compliance with the myriad regulations and taxes which are a barrier to entry.”

Seems a valid point to us. Think of how much more competitive individuals working in the area between the Atlantic and the Pacific Oceans (say) would be if they were allowed to conduct business with whomsoever they wished and on their own, mutually agreed-upon terms. Millions of job-seekers could be put to work immediately. The state-sponsored unemployment problem would disappear overnight. It’s not as if there is no work to be done, after all.

This line of thinking begs the obvious question: if one could voluntarily contract work between two or more willing individuals, why involve the government at all? This is the basic concept behind System D. The state, as we know, is nothing but the ultimate, glorified middle man. And costly, too! For the benefit of having this “silent partner” – who, by the way, contributes absolutely zip to the start up of your business, neither in time, nor capital, nor to the ongoing production of it – you will be charged roughly half of your total profits. Moreover, you will be expected to act as the unpaid accountant and tax collector for this partner, who demands that you withhold wages from your employees so that it may confiscate them later. Who would voluntarily agree to such demeaning, demoralizing deal?

As it turns out, the state itself knows exactly how many people would “opt” for its services if actually given the freedom to choose. How do we know this? The actions of the state tell us so, and clearly. If you know somebody wants to do business with you, if you are confident you are offering a valuable good or service at a competitive price, do you hold a gun to your potential customer’s head? Of course not. But that’s exactly what the state does when “offering” its “services.” It says, without apology:

You will use our currency, and no other, or we will label you a “domestic terrorist” and throw you in jail. You will carry our identifying documents, and no others, or we will not permit you to leave these boundaries (as defined by our wars with other states). You will surrender a certain portion of your private property to us annually, or we will lock you up. And if you try to escape our cage, you will be shot.

Does that sound like a confident businessman striving to provide the best service for his customers? Hardly. This is more like the behaviour of a jealous, insecure megalomaniac. As far as “silent” partners go, the state is more screaming, bellowing psychopath than hands-off onlooker. And, we hasten to add, it is armed to the teeth.

All in all, it’s a nasty affair this statism. Which is why System D is so very appealing for the millions of individuals who, despite the threat of the state and its various means of violence and coercion, decide to do business without its foul, unwanted blessing anyway.

Now, before readers disparage the “black market scourge” as merely a bunch of crims, cons and bloodsucking shysters lurking on in the shadows of civil society, allow us to consider the true nature of its participants. They could be anyone from a 4-year old lemonade vendor who decides to set up camp on mom and dad’s front lawn without the necessary government permit, to a peer-2-peer cyber crypto-currency currently enabling millions of dollars worth of transactions between freely-associating individuals around the world. And any of the brave, freedom-loving individuals in between. Simply, it consists of people who don’t hold guns to other people’s heads in order to conduct business with them.

Besides all that, if its crims, cons and bloodsucking shysters that are cause for concern, one need look no further than Washington D.C. and the various capital cities around the world where the rest of the guns-for-hire reside in taxpayer-provided comfort and leisure.

To furnish but one recent example: In the “Land of the Free, Home of the Brave”, a Nobel Peace Prize-winning president and the “Leader of the Free World,” who also happens to be an expert in constitutional law and who spent a dozen years lecturing on the subject at the University of Chicago Law School, signed into law the National Defense Authorization Act, thereby granting himself – and future presidents – permission to incarcerate, indefinitely and without their recourse to counsel, trial or due process, any American citizen he or she deems, unilaterally, to be in need of detention…Great Writ be damned.

In a deafening act of bi-partisanship, the bill arrived on the president’s desk as passed by a “deeply divided” Congress…with overwhelming majorities in both the House and the Senate.

Arguing that free markets won’t work because there will still exist exactly the kind of morally bankrupt persons currently enjoying institutionalized positions of power is circular logic at its finest. Free markets don’t promise to get rid of these worms. They just promise not to provide an unchallengeable framework through which they may be promoted to the highest seats in the land…then gifted your tax slave number in the one hand and the nuclear codes in the other.

Joel Bowman

Joel Bowman is a contributor to The Daily Reckoning. After completing his degree in media communications and journalism in his home country of Australia, Joel moved to Baltimore to join the Agora Financial team. His keen interest in travel and macroeconomics first took him to New York where he regularly reported from Wall Street, and he now writes from and lives all over the world.

  • Chris

    I am sure if you re-arranged the letters in the word: statism, you could almost come up with satanism !

Recent Articles

Extra!
Missing Money: What Government Accounting Really Looks Like

Jeff Desjardins

Everyone knows how comically terrible government accounting is, but few people may realize just how bad it's gotten... This infographic shows how trillions of dollars of government money has gone missing money over the last several years. And what's worse... that no one seems to care where it went...


Sage Advice for Bored Investors

Chris Mayer

It's amazing what some people will do out of sheer boredom. Investors, for example, will often throw money around, simply because they have nothing better to do - as if making MORE moves automatically translates to MORE money. Today, Chris Mayer explains why this emotion is so dangerous and how staving it off can save you a ton of money...


The One Word Every IPO Investor Needs to Know

Jonas Elmerraji

When a big company IPOs, investors can hardly contain their excitement. In a flash of exuberance, they throw money at a company they've already decided is worth something... even if the market hasn't made up its mind yet. Today, Jonas Elmerraji explains how one simple word can change the fate of every IPO investor. Read on...


How to Escape Obamacare in One Bold Move

Chris Campbell

Think it's impossible to escape the throes of Obamacare? Think again. Today, Chris Campbell relays the story of one man was able to get out from under the (un)Affordable Care Act, and how you can do it too. Don't see another doctor, take another pill, or shop around for better medical insurance until you read his story...


Let the Alibaba IPO Show You Where the Market’s Headed

Greg Guenthner

For the last few days, the market has been buzzing with excitement over the Alibaba IPO. Well, the day is finally here. And while some investors line up with their lotto tickets, ready to snatch it up no matter what the price, Greg Guenthner suggests a slightly more restrained approach. Read on...