Jeffrey Tucker

When I was a kid, lawn mowers worked. You pushed them and they cut grass. The grass went into the bag. Then you emptied the bag. The results were great. There was no grass to rake. It all went into the bag, because that’s what lawn mowers did.

Then the feds got involved. Or so I now gather. I didn’t know this for a long time. Every time I would buy a mower, I would be disappointed in the results. I kept buying mowers with ever-larger engines. Then I would buy them with different bag designs, and then a different brands, and then different features. Nothing worked.

The problem was always the same. I would mow and most of the grass would go in the catcher. But some didn’t. Some landed on the lawn in a line. When the grass was wet, it left an even bigger trail. Or when I would go from the grass to the sidewalk, a big clump would fall out from underneath the mower onto the sidewalk, requiring that I get a broom and sweep it up. Then I would have to empty the bag long before it was full.

It took me many years of thinking to figure out the problem. After all, I never had this problem when I was a kid. Have companies started making lawn mowers that don’t work? Are manufacturers worse than they used to be? It all seems crazy. I would mow with a smartphone in my pocket that could check my blood pressure, make the sound of a flute or surf the Web. Why can’t private enterprise seem to make a mower that works?

I would try to forget about the problem, adjust to the downgraded reality and finish up the growing season. But the next year, it would all come back to me. Grass trails. Clumps on the sidewalk. Emptying too often. Buying a new mower and finding the same problem all over again.

What is the source of the problem? The spinning blade cuts the grass and creates a flow of air that lifts the grass and throws it into the catcher. A flow requires circulation, and where does the circulation come from? It can’t be a vacuum seal. You can’t create a small wind tunnel without a source of air. Where is this coming from? Nowhere. The base of the lawn mower is flush against the grass. The blades spin but create no suction effect.

Why is the base so low to the ground? I tend to mow my grass pretty low just because of the variety of grass and the topsoil level. But doing this causes a perfect seal between the mower and the ground, cutting off all airflow and denying the blade the air it needs to create the wind tunnel to empty the grass.

It is pretty obvious, right? So why have manufacturers not responded by raising the steel casing on the lawn mower? Why would they keep selling mowers that don’t work well? I’m hardly the only person who has the problem. Lawn mower forums all over the Internet are filled with people asking exactly the same questions and having the same symptoms. The manufacturers are shy to mention the real reason. They talk about changing blades, removing obstructions and things like that. Users know better. There is another factor.

I was just looking at the detailed regulations for lawn mowers. In particular, the relevant passage is 16 CFR PART 1205 — the Safety Standard for Walk-Behind Power Lawn Mowers. Here we find that the height of the lawn mower case must be low enough to pass a “foot probe” test. No matter how high or low the wheels are adjusted, it cannot be possible to stick your foot under the case.

Now, when I was young, you could stick your foot under the mower. We didn’t do that, of course, but we could. Therefore, there was suction. The air sucked from underneath and swirled up and out in the grass catcher. It was like running a vacuum cleaner over a floor. It shaved the grass, and not one grass blade was left anywhere in sight. It all went into the catcher.

The new regulations, which apply only to walking mowers that you use at home, went into effect sometime after 1982. I still used my old mower for years after that date. I fact, I didn’t have a reason to buy a new one until about 15 years ago. That’s when my troubles began.

Now I know the cause. The bottom line is that federal regulations have degraded the lawn mower. In the name of safety, the government has forced all manufacturers to sacrifice functionality. They are forced to sell equipment that doesn’t do what it is supposed to do. All the while, I’ve been blaming private enterprise. It turns out to be the fault of government.

The government’s central plan for walk-behind mowers is mind boggling. That bar you have to squeeze and hold on the handle to make the wheel move? Mandated by government. That annoying plastic piece that covers the blow hole for the grass that you have to push out of the way? Mandated by government. The government has mandated the blueprint for the whole machine and thereby frozen its structure in place with an inferior and unalterable design.

It is not enough that regulations have invaded the bathroom, ruined our showers and toilets, degraded our detergent, made it ever harder to unclog drains and made essential medicines hard to get. Now I find that regulations have even made it difficult for me to do something completely American like mow my own lawn!

It is now as it was in the 19th century when Herbert Spencer wrote his amazing work, The Man Versus The State. It remains a powerful explanatory essay about what is wrong with the world and what to do about it.

This also explains why so many of my neighbors are using lawn mowing services that have giant riding lawn mowers. It turns out that these particular regulations do not apply to them. It wouldn’t surprise me to find that lawn services were actually instrumental in lobbying for these safety regulations. This is how commerce works these days: Compete for a while, but when that doesn’t work, turn to the government to wreck the competition.

Government hates lawns — except at the White House, of course. They consider private lawns to be wasteful and vain, a symbol of conspicuous consumption. If they had their way, we would all have rocks in our front yards. Or maybe we wouldn’t have front yards. We would have little window boxes, and surely that would be enough for us.

It’s all in the interest of your safety. And security. What about your freedom? It’s been mowed under, and it landed like clumps of grass on the sidewalk.


Jeffrey Tucker

Jeffrey Tucker
  • Adrienne

    Get a mulching blade and quit bagging. Better for the lawn. And if you’re ending up with big clumps you’re either not cutting often enough or you’re cutting too short.

    About those regs. My newest riding mower won’t back up unless you put the key in a certain position. If you don’t. the mower stops. Can’t have you backing over your kids, unless, of course, you move the key position in which case it’s perfectly okay to chop up your kid. The consumer pays more for this little thingy which is ridiculous.

  • Pingback: They Wrecked Our Mowers « Financial Survival Network

  • Isaac

    Couldn’t you just ether drill holes along the bottom or cut the guard higher on the sides.

  • Michael

    Elites don’t mow their own lawns. They hire illegals to do it.

  • Josh

    I’m thinking the same thing as Isaac. If we can modify our mowers to allow the necessary air flow while still keeping them safe then so could manufacturers and that would give them a competitive edge. Something here doesn’t add up.

  • Pingback: They Wrecked Our Mowers « Evil of indifference

  • http://- Ron

    Buy and install Bigger Steel Wheels, Lowes or Home Depot. Unadvisable for Safety reasons but a cable tie around the safety bar to hold it in takes care of that annoyance. Stop the mower by shorting the sparkplug to ground with a screwdriver.

  • Kenny

    I had a similar experience just yesterday with my rental. Here is the quote from the repairman : By this time next year the new department of energy furnace regulations will be in place and 80% furnaces will no longer be allowed. The minimum efficiency wil be 90% after April 30, 2013. A 90%+ efficiency furnace would be $2700 installed.
    The government is driving up the cost for me to replace my heater by 33%. For many, $900 takes quite a bit of energy to produce. Perhaps the HVAC companies At least they haven’t outlawed my fireplace, yet.

  • Desertrat

    Home handyman fix: An acetylene wrench takes care of creating the draft. Ever notice how some people remove that little flap-door from the back of a mower? Or how baling wire takes care of the dead-man’s throttle and clutch?

    When I built my house, I got stuck with these low-flush (no-flush) toilets. I examined the “system”. Sheet metal shears let me cut vee-notches in the sides of the little plastic flow-reducing bucket. Now my wife is a happy person.

    And all my gray water goes onto plants, not into the septic system.

    Don’t like seat belt buzzers and blinking lights when you don’t want to use the belt? Easy fix: Cut a little aluminum tab, stick it in the buckle and live a happier life.

    There is a lot to be said for being a do-it-yourselfer.

  • Pingback: Articles for Sunday » Scott Lazarowitz's Blog

  • Pingback: Signs of Spring that make me CRAZY « fourkidsandthemom

  • Ray

    Notice what else is missing? No adjustable throttle anymore.
    It’s either running or it’s not.

  • Jack

    You could still blame private enterprise. Why not make a lawn mower that has a 1/4 – 1/2 inch slit around the edge on both sides? It would then allow air to flow freely.

  • Josef Pitta

    I was trying to find the song on the internet, anyway… I bumped into this site. You should check out. It’s not just music.

  • Pingback: Trackback

Recent Articles

5 Min. Forecast
How to Profit On the Back of an “Activist Investor”

Dave Gonigam

Since the invention of the "shareholder rights plan" (i.e. the "poison pill"), most companies are relatively immune to hostile takeovers. But according to Dave Gonigam that could all change thanks to one activist investor. And if you're savvy enough, you may just be able to follow his lead for big gains. Read on...

Why Americans Shouldn’t Worry About Income Inequality

Jim Mosquera

As the markets have continued to rally over the last several years, more and more people have touted the problem of "income inequality" in the US. But as Jim Mosquera explains, this perceived problem will likely sort itself out with the arrival of one specific market event. Read on...

One ETF to Play Asymmetric Warfare

Addison Wiggin

Almost one year ago, substation telephone cables were maliciously cut in San Jose, CA. In 20 minutes, 17 transformers were knocked out. A year on, similar threats have cropped up. Today, Addison Wiggin explains why these threats are so serious for the safety of the global economy... and shows you one way to play it...

What Small-Caps are Saying About the Current “Bubble”

Greg Guenthner

The big problem with declaring bubbles is that it really does you no good. Unless you're attempting to measure and time market moves, you're also blowing hot air. But if you keep watch for negative divergences, you have a much better shot at figuring out big market moves than the latest bubble-busters. Greg Guenthner explains...

A Simple Strategy for Investing in the US Energy Boom

Byron King

Too often investments are made in a vacuum. But as Byron King demonstrates, the global economic crash... easy money... and technological advancements are all interdependent. In particular, that connection has changed the investment calculus in the resource market. Read on to learn how...

How Gold Will Respond to Declining Discovery

Henry Bonner

Oil isn't the only resource to experience "peaks." Due to a major contraction in gold exploration over the past few years, the mining sector is no longer mining gold at its replacement rate. In other words, the amount of gold above ground is running out. And according to Henry Bonner, it will get worse before it gets better...