Greg Guenthner

After years shunning anything that even smelled like a stock, investors collectively decided to throw record amounts of cash at the market last month.

The whole situation was baffling. People don’t usually change their attitudes that quickly — especially when it comes to investments. So you can understand why record stock fund inflows coupled with this huge rally became a bit of a concern.

However, some new numbers show some sanity has entered the fray. As it turns out, the average investor isn’t going all-in this early in the game…

S&P 500 vs. Investor Movement Index

TD Ameritrade’s Investor Movement index shows that even as stocks continue to rise, investors haven’t been shy about hitting the sell button.

Why bother looking at a proprietary TD Ameritrade indicator? Because those are the guys that have your money. They know when you buy and when you sell. Their information is based on actual investor behavior — not some survey.

In the newest data, you can see a big divergence emerging on the chart. Investors are getting defensive while the S&P 500 cruises higher.

So what the hell does it all mean?

Short answer: I’m not completely sure…

The divergence might end up as nothing more than an anomaly. But the index doesn’t reach back too far — so it’s difficult to say how the market might react as it slumps.

What we do know is that investors aren’t as gung-ho as we thought just a couple of weeks ago. The emotional climate has found some balance.

That’s helpful when it comes to the longevity of this rally — and the hopes that the market will pull itself out of the sludge bucket affectionately known as the lost decade.

Best,

Greg Guenthner
for The Daily Reckoning

Greg Guenthner

Greg Guenthner, CMT, is the managing editor of The Rude Awakening. Greg is a member of the Market Technicians Association and holds the Chartered Market Technician designation.

  • http://www.facebook.com/mcgoverntm Thomas McGovern

    How can the market go up if people are generally taking their money out of the market? It can’t. TD Ameritrade customers may be taking their money out, but for the market to go up others have to be putting their money in. If that is so, of what value is the TD Ameritrade indicator?

  • Noel G.

    I’m not a stock market investor so my question my lack knowledge, but are you sure it’s investors? With so much underhandedness in the markets, how can anyone be sure it’s not being propped up in some way so that the big money can pull out and leaving the average American holding the bag?

  • http://www.facebook.com/mcgoverntm Thomas McGovern

    It may be market manipulators, similar to Greenspan’s “Plunge Protection Team.” If so, my question still stands: of what value is the TD Ameritrade indicator?

Recent Articles

Housing Bulls Gave Up Here… Big Mistake

Greg Guenthner

Another one of Wall Street’s broken forecasts has plopped a new trade in your lap. If you’re listening to the lunatics on the financial news, you’re hearing that there’s no hope for the markets. Just get rid of your stocks and pound sand. Better safe than sorry—none of these talking heads want to get bullish on anything right now because they’re afraid to look like an idiot if the market keeps dropping. For them, selling stocks now is your only chance to make it to the end of the year without pawning the family cat to buy Christmas presents. Can the market survive? Greg Guenthner explains…


A Quarter-Century’s Conclusion on Our Cancer Woes

Ray Blanco

Breakthrough technologies can hold the most undiscovered money-making potential. What we’ve accomplished in a quarter century with cancer research could make you serious money and save countless lives. Ray Blanco has more on this ground breaking story...


Give Your Book Away For Free, Make More Money

Chris Campbell

The publishing industry is on its head. These days, it makes more sense to make money before you write your book and give it away for free once you do. In today’s Laissez Faire Today, Chris Campbell shows you how to create a hit with those two counterintuitive steps. Read on…


Why Malpractice from the Fed Will Undermine Growth

Steve Forbes

The latest friend of ours to weigh in on the topic of the value of your money is Steve Forbes. As you’ve been reading this week, we paid a visit to Mr. Forbes recently, to discuss his latest book, Money. In this essay, you’ll find his thoughts on currency devaluation… it’s impact of economic growth and your investments…


Why We Hold Hard Assets II

Henry Bonner

Right now we’re seeing a surge of strength in the U.S. dollar, as the bottom falls out of our competitors’ currencies, and Jim Grant has the best analysis of what it means for investors. For one, it means the Federal Reserve can’t keep interest rates low forever. And mainstream investors may be very surprised when the Fed gives in…