Greg Guenthner

After years shunning anything that even smelled like a stock, investors collectively decided to throw record amounts of cash at the market last month.

The whole situation was baffling. People don’t usually change their attitudes that quickly — especially when it comes to investments. So you can understand why record stock fund inflows coupled with this huge rally became a bit of a concern.

However, some new numbers show some sanity has entered the fray. As it turns out, the average investor isn’t going all-in this early in the game…

S&P 500 vs. Investor Movement Index

TD Ameritrade’s Investor Movement index shows that even as stocks continue to rise, investors haven’t been shy about hitting the sell button.

Why bother looking at a proprietary TD Ameritrade indicator? Because those are the guys that have your money. They know when you buy and when you sell. Their information is based on actual investor behavior — not some survey.

In the newest data, you can see a big divergence emerging on the chart. Investors are getting defensive while the S&P 500 cruises higher.

So what the hell does it all mean?

Short answer: I’m not completely sure…

The divergence might end up as nothing more than an anomaly. But the index doesn’t reach back too far — so it’s difficult to say how the market might react as it slumps.

What we do know is that investors aren’t as gung-ho as we thought just a couple of weeks ago. The emotional climate has found some balance.

That’s helpful when it comes to the longevity of this rally — and the hopes that the market will pull itself out of the sludge bucket affectionately known as the lost decade.

Best,

Greg Guenthner
for The Daily Reckoning

Greg Guenthner

Greg Guenthner, CMT, is the managing editor of The Rude Awakening. Greg is a member of the Market Technicians Association and holds the Chartered Market Technician designation.

  • http://www.facebook.com/mcgoverntm Thomas McGovern

    How can the market go up if people are generally taking their money out of the market? It can’t. TD Ameritrade customers may be taking their money out, but for the market to go up others have to be putting their money in. If that is so, of what value is the TD Ameritrade indicator?

  • Noel G.

    I’m not a stock market investor so my question my lack knowledge, but are you sure it’s investors? With so much underhandedness in the markets, how can anyone be sure it’s not being propped up in some way so that the big money can pull out and leaving the average American holding the bag?

  • http://www.facebook.com/mcgoverntm Thomas McGovern

    It may be market manipulators, similar to Greenspan’s “Plunge Protection Team.” If so, my question still stands: of what value is the TD Ameritrade indicator?

Recent Articles

Peter Thiel Explains What Backs the U.S. Dollar

Chris Mayer

In a recent interview, Peter Thiel gave a simple and clear explanation of what gives the U.S. dollar its power. “It surprised me,” writes Chris Mayer, “because I had not heard anyone but fringe economists give it. And yet it is the key to understanding modern money.” Chris revisits the idea… including some radical ideas “that will change the way you think of money and the economy forever.”


Could Steak Really Cause Arthritis?

Stephen Petranek

Can you really eat more salt? Is arthritis caused by steak? Are artificial sweeteners really Satan’s sugar? Stephen Petranek comes clean about 2014’s wackiest health recommendations in his new series on “The Truth About MD Warnings.”


Now’s the Time to Buy Housing Stocks – While They’re Cheap

Greg Guenthner

So let me point out one of the new clues for you: construction hiring is actually on the mend after years of decline. Contractors added 48,000 jobs in December, according to the latest numbers. Full-year numbers were also better than expected, clocking in at 9-year highs. Why is no one talking about that?


The Currency Wars’ “Pearl Harbor”

James Rickards

The most dramatic battle yet in the currency wars took place last Thursday. It was the financial equivalent of a Pearl Harbor sneak attack. Jim Rickards has the full story... what it means moving forward... and a lesson for all gold investors...


Why Oil Can’t Stay Cheap

Byron King

As consumers, you want to see low prices at the pump. But for investors who've been riding the American fracking boom, are these low prices a death knell? Byron’s advice to you, as an investor with exposure to energy stocks, is to not panic in the face of short-term market turmoil. And Byron’s got two picks primed to rebound…