Douglas French

“There’s an old saying in Tennessee,” the last president said in a classic George W. Bush gem. “I know it’s in Texas, probably in Tennessee — that says, ‘Fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you can’t get fooled again.'”

Well, you know what he meant.

But seriously, though, really; this time is really, really different. At least that’s what they want you to believe.

BlackRock’s Larry Fink told CNBC a few days ago that the Dow Jones Industrial Average could hit 28,000 in six years. That’s nothing; professional investor Ron Baron says the DJIA could be around 50,000 or 60,000 in 20 years.

The use of iPhones, iPads, and various and sundry technological devices must have destroyed our memories. Last I knew, we had all been collectively chuckling since the year 2000, when James Glassman and Kevin Hassett released a book entitled Dow 36,000: The New Strategy for Profiting From the Coming Rise in the Stock Market.

A year before that, David Elias came out with a book called Dow 40,000: Strategies for Profiting From the Greatest Bull Market in History. On the back cover of the book, the author speculated:

“Well-Researched Strategies to Soar With the Dow to 40,000 and Beyond! Date: June 2, 2016. DOW BREAKS 40,000! ‘The Dow Jones Industrial Average, for the first time in history, today broke through the once unthinkable 40,000 barrier. Leading market experts predict the market will continue to rocket upward.'”

Of course, these authors had the bad luck to publish books right as the Nasdaq and the Dow were peaking, and it was pretty much downhill from there. Cheap Fed money after Sept. 11 elevated financial and housing stocks (and houses), and the market rebounded again until the spanking in 2008.

Well, here we are again. Except it’s different, again.

James Surowiecki at The New Yorker says it’s the skeptics that are delusional. The mere fact that everyone is shouting “bubble” in this crowded market doesn’t mean there is a bubble, but in fact means there isn’t one, he says.

We’re all bubble-phobic, says the scribe. Given the recent bubbles and crashes, investors suffer from post-traumatic bubble disorder. There’s a bubble around every corner. We don’t fear the boogeyman, but the bubbleman.

Surowiecki writes:

“The argument for a stock-market bubble is flawed: When it comes to the role that corporations play in the U.S. economy, the present looks very different from the past, which means that historical comparisons to the 1950s, let alone the ’30s, tell us little. The four most dangerous words in investing may be, ‘This time, it’s different.’ But this time, it is different.”

What makes this time different, than the ’30s and the ’50s, says Surowiecki, is that taxes are lower and labor is cheaper, so these outsized corporate profits make all the sense in the world. Stock market valuations, therefore, are, if not in line with historic norms, conservative. Plus, there’s globalization, he says. Multinational companies are making nearly half their profits overseas.

Surowiecki figures, “keeping profits where they are doesn’t look all that difficult, which makes stocks today quite reasonably priced.”

This whole globalization thing has been going on for a long time. As far as taxes go, Surowiecki cites 50% rates from the ’50s and 30% rates from the ’60s. There have been plenty of booms and busts in the present tax environment. He acts like the decline of union labor happened yesterday. The peak for union labor was 35% of the U.S. workforce in the mid-’50s. It was down to just over 20% in 1983. It’s been in the teens as a percentage of the workforce since the 1990s.

After making all of these fundamental arguments that essentially tie the health of the stock market to the health of company earnings tied to the health of the economy, near the end of his piece, Surowiecki writes, “It’s unsettling that companies and investors are doing so well while the economy as a whole is stuck in the mud.”

He makes the same mistake other pundits and investors make. A mistake Mark Skousen pointed out years ago in his book Investing in One Lesson — Wall Street is not Main Street. “A stock is a unique entity; its price is affected by factors different from those that determine the value of an individual company.” Skousen emphasizes, “Remember: The business of investing is not the same as investing in a business.”

At market tops, there are always ways to rationalize higher prices. Whether the subject prices are for tulip bulbs, houses, stocks, bonds, country club memberships, or baseball cards. Fools can always imagine greater fools. And fools can always find financing, until they can’t. For now, New York Stock Exchange margin debt, which is money used to leverage bets on stocks, in April eclipsed the previous all-time high set in July 2007.

And while Surowiecki contends the market is no “house of cards, held up by easy money and investor delusion,” Ben Bernanke has made no bones about trying to elevate markets with money that may not be easy, but is certainly cheap, believing people with improving wealth will start spending. Bernanke wants savers out of cash chasing stock market returns.

However, Alec Macfie writes in Laissez Faire Club selection Theories of the Trade Cycle that gains made in stock trading spent on consumption “represent nothing but exaggerated hopes.” Macfie quotes R.G. Hawtrey “toward the end… people… were using their resources to back nothing more substantial than a continuance of the good luck which had brought big gains to their neighbors.”

One investor who has made boatloads in his career thinks now is the time to sell, not buy. Leon Black of the Apollo Group shops for value but can’t find any. While participating on a panel of investing stars at the recent conference of private equity managers put on by the Milken Institute, Black said, “We think it’s a fabulous environment to be selling into. We’re selling everything that’s not nailed down in our portfolio. It’s almost biblical — you know, there’s a time to reap; there’s a time to sow — and right now we are harvesting.”

Resource investing guru and Vancouver favorite Rick Rule points out often that an investor can either be a contrarian or a victim. Mr. Surowiecki wants to make you believe that it is the bulls who are the contrarians. However, stock indexes and margin debt don’t make highs at (or near) market bottoms.

Don’t be fooled again.


Doug French
Original article posted on Laissez Faire Today

Douglas French

Douglas French is a Senior Editor for Agora Financial. He received his master's degree under the direction of Murray N. Rothbard at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, after many years in the business of banking. He is the author of two books, Early Speculative Bubbles & Increases in the Money Supply, the first major empirical study of the relationship between early bubbles and the money supply, and Walk Away, a monograph assessing the philosophy and morality of strategic default. He is founder and editor of LibertyWatch magazine.

Recent Articles

Can Money Printing Cause Deflation?

Marc Faber

"There has been an issue that has preoccupied my mind for a long time," writes Dr. Marc Faber. "In economics, it is generally accepted that if the quantity of money and credit is increased, prices will rise… However, since economics is so complex… I question whether the expansion of central banks' balance sheets and policies of zero interest rates could have a deflationary impact…" The good doctor wrestles with the question, in today's essay...

Forget the Oil Crash – Crush the Market With Biotech Stocks

Greg Guenthner

The Biotech iShares ETF is up 23% since the Oct. 15th bottom. No, that is not a typo. Biotechs have torched the S&P over the past two months--more than doubling the returns of the big index. And biotechs as a group are up more than 38% year-to-date. In fact, since we first highlighted the June comeback, the Biotech iShares have gone nowhere but up.

How Low Will Oil Go – And What Can You Do?

Matt Insley

The oil market has been under siege for six months. From service providers to producers this downturn has been painful. Of course, we’ve known all along that oil prices were a little toppy over the summer. In fact, when asked just how low oil prices could go I usually answered with a simple “lower than you’d expect…”

Cuba’s Berlin Wall Moment

Peter Coyne

Our forecast that Cuba would be open and integrated within 5-10 years is on track after yesterday's big announcement. Ahead of schedule, even. Click here to see how some investors have profited and what the island's likely future is...

The $4 LED Trend You Don’t Want to Miss

Chris Mayer

The opportunity to sell and install LEDs is enormous. We’re talking about over a billion lighting fixtures. And the areas with the largest potential -- like parking lots -- have barely begun to change. Banker to the presidents Chris Mayer says you could triple your money in this new tech trend. Here's what you need to know.

How to Make the Casinos Pay You for a Change

Greg Guenthner

It's a theme we've shared with you since April. And it's only gotten worse. The gaming industry has come under all sorts of pressure--a situation I first noticed in the charts. The powerful, multi-year uptrends started showing cracks. And it wasn't long before those cracks turned into gaping holes you could drive a friggin' truck through. That's where things stand today.