Chris Mayer

In an email to my Capital & Crisis readers on March 22, I shared a great speech by Dean Williams, then a senior vice president at Batterymarch Financial. (Delivered in 1981, it was called Trying Too Hard.) The speech was full of great advice, including the following:

“There are two ways we can try to gain an edge over the market. The one most of us choose is to try to generate superior information, to know more than anyone else. The other choice is to be better at measuring value than others and not to care very much about what other investors think they know. To hold cheaper securities by today’s standards and let the future speak for itself.”

My path is the latter. Of course, this begs the question: What’s objectively cheap by today’s standards?

I have a few answers.

Gold stocks are cheap.

One way to see this fact comes from John Doody, editor of The Gold Stock Analyst. Doody compares the price of gold per ounce in the average gold stock as a percentage of the gold price. (Technically, he compares the market cap per ounce of proven and probable reserves against the gold price.) It yields a, shall we say, highly suggestive result.

Doody finds that gold stocks currently trade for just 13% of the current price of gold. Put another way, you can buy an ounce of gold by owning a gold stock and pay just $207 an ounce. From 2002-07, the market valued the gold of gold stocks at 38% of the price of gold. Ever since 2007, the percentage has been dropping. And it currently sits at just 13% — the lowest since at least 2001.

As Doody notes, to get to 38% from here, gold stocks would have to triple. We own a pair of gold stocks, both down. Doody, a masterful gold stock picker with a track record better than anyone I know of in this sector, has a portfolio full of losers. It’s a tough time for gold stock investors, which is a sign in itself.

Bank stocks are also cheap.

One way to see their low valuations is to look at price-to-tangible book value per share. I’m not saying price to book holds all the answers. But it is a pretty good, objective proxy for cheapness, much like Doody’s percentage measure on gold stocks. It’s also wonderfully simple.

Let’s break down banks into three buckets by asset size. Those with less than $1 billion in assets go in bucket one. Those with $1-10 billion in assets go in bucket two. And bucket three is for the banks with assets above $10 billion. The median multiples for each bucket compared with its 20-year average look like this:

A Different Kind of Bucket List

Put another way, these stocks trade for 71%, 74% and 64%, respectively, of their long-term averages. Skeptics would say there are good reasons why bank stocks are cheap. Look at earnings, they’d say. Median price-earnings ratios are around 95% of the 20-year average.

“Yes, but,” says I “profits move in cycles. They will rebound.” When it happens is anybody’s guess. As an investor, you focus on what you know today. And what we know today is bank multiples sit well below their 20-year averages.

According to Jeff Davis: “Historically, when bank multiples rose above the 20-year average, returns tended to be poor over the ensuing one- to two-year period and vice versa.” We’re in the “vice versa” scenario now.

Davis, by the way, is the managing director of Mercer Capital’s financial institutions group. He writes a good blog for SNL Financial. Mercer has spent “30 years studying equity market returns” and what goes into the mixing bowl that makes them. I got my figures above from him.

Importantly, bank acquisitions are still going off at 1.2 times book and greater. These takeovers make tremendous sense, as the buyer can lower costs and improve the economics of the bank. Larger banks, too, enjoy better valuations.

The odds of placing winning bets are extremely high in bank stocks, if you’ve got anything more than the patience of a gnat.

What else is objectively cheap?

Insurance stocks.

I add insurance stocks for much the same reason as banks. It is easy to find insurance stocks selling below book value, at the lower end of valuations ratios going back 10 and 20 years.

Here is a chart of EMC Insurance (NASDAQ:EMCI) going back 10 years. It shows the price-to-book ratio steadily falling over time.

EMCI: One of Many Such Fish in the Sea

There are plenty of good insurers for which I could draw similar charts. Many of the same criticisms leveled at banks apply to insurers. The profitability of these businesses is also at cyclical lows.

As an investor, the cheap sectors I have highlighted are exactly the kinds of situations that ought to attract your attention… and capital. Nothing exciting needs to happen to make a good return. You just need to see a return to average — a reversion to the mean.

Eventually, these things work themselves out, and investors make lots of money when they do. At bottom, that’s the basis of Dean’s sage advice.

Regards,

Chris Mayer
for The Daily Reckoning

P.S. Sometimes a stock is cheap because it’s worthless. But other times, as we point out above, a stock may be cheap because investors are simply unable (or unwilling) to see the bigger picture. Readers of The Daily Reckoning email edition receive regular opportunities to discover for themselves just these types of scenarios. If you’re not already a subscriber, you’re missing out. Sign up for free, right here.

You May Also Like:


Trading an Undercover Rally

Greg Guenthner

It's true... 2014 has not been a kind year for stocks so far. And even though the markets rallied a bit yesterday, it wasn't enough to fully release the panic button just yet. But yesterday's uptick did reveal a hidden rally that could play out quite nicely for savvy investors as the year progresses. Greg Guenthner has more...

Chris Mayer

Chris Mayer is managing editor of the Capital and Crisis and Mayer's Special Situations newsletters. Graduating magna cum laude with a degree in finance and an MBA from the University of Maryland, he began his business career as a corporate banker. Mayer left the banking industry after ten years and signed on with Agora Financial. His book, Invest Like a Dealmaker, Secrets of a Former Banking Insider, documents his ability to analyze macro issues and micro investment opportunities to produce an exceptional long-term track record of winning ideas. In April 2012, Chris released his newest book World Right Side Up: Investing Across Six Continents

Recent Articles

Laissez Faire
The Only Solution for the Obamacare Problem

Loren Heal

Politicians talk about the uninsured. Special interests argue on behalf of those with pre-existing conditions. But why is no one wondering how doctors are affected by Obamacare? They're the ones on the front lines dealing directly with new patients, as well as the red tape that makes bureaucracies go round. Loren Heal explores further...


Huge Gains From Smart Money With No Sex Appeal

Greg Guenthner

Since the beginning of March, hedge funds have been steadily moving out of growth stocks. So it's not coincidence this sector has fallen in tandem. But the question is, where is the "smart money" headed now? Greg Guenthner examines the current, decidedly "unsexy" trend in the market. Read on...


Extra!
High Frequency Trading: An Aid to Economic Collapse

John Rubino

Thanks in part to Michael Lewis's book Flash Boys, High Frequency Trading (HFT) is front and center for this round of the news cycle. Today, John Rubino continues the discussion, explaing why HFT is so dangerous, and how public awareness of it is affecting something called the "trust horizon." Read on...


Maestro
How a Central Bank Really Shapes the Economy

David Stockman

As the saying goes, there are two things you never want to see being made: laws and sausages. But to hear David Stockman tell it, there could be a third thing added to that list: how crony capitalists make money. Today, Mr. Stockman gives a complete rundown of how this corrupt system really functions, and why it makes him ill. Read on...


Video
The Art of Central Banking

Kate Incontrera

If you look at all the measurements, number crunching and financial instruments that are employed at the Federal Reserve, you may come to the conclusion that economics is a science. However, in his speech at the 2013 Agora Financial Investment Symposium, Bill Bonner explains why that couldn't be further from the truth...


5 Min. Forecast
Big Gains from an Earnings Season Surprise

Dave Gonigam

It's earnings season, and that means the "expectations game" is in full swing. Of course, with so much speculation involved, this often ends up being a "contradiction game" between various media outlets. Today, Dave Gonigam explains how to sift through the noise and play a few earnings surprises for big gains. Read on...